QUESTION FIVE
A key element in the connoisseurship and criticism approach of Elliot Eisner is expertise. A person who has it looks at the world differently, and is more qualified to conduct inquiry than a person who does not. Setting aside for a moment your natural reticence to extol your own qualifications, describe the elements of expertise that you would bring to your study of the teacher’s cultural realm in the question above, as well as your assessment of the parameters and limitations of that expertise. Be sure to include attitudinal, cognitive, and motor skill dimensions as applicable. (Note: your response to this question should not shape how you respond(ed) to question #4 above).
FROM MY PERSPECTIVE
What elements of expertise could I bring to the research scenario in the previous question? Well, let’s say that I’ve been working with this really great research team to figure out how to learn more about the teacher’s realm. But a teacher’s classroom is a tough realm to get into, forget about getting into it without altering the environment.
But wait, Elliot Eisner lends insight to our research plight (1991). One must drink deeply to savor his incredible wisdom, so more about that in a minute. Like Dr. Eisner, I’ve been a public school teacher for many years. Like him, I have a certain fetish about the arts. Actually it’s a good thing that everybody on our research team doesn’t share Dr. Eisner’s views as much as I do. Our diversity helps us to balance out each other’s biases.
I take Dr. Eisner’s interesting French term, connoisseurship, as synonymous with expertise. The two terms can be used interchangeably. Expertise implies the qualitative nuances and energy that come of metacognitive processes and transfer (Bransford, Brown, and Cocking, 2000), just as connoisseurship does. Criticism follows connoisseurship. The educational critic provides a public face for connoisseurship by communicating what is perceived. One cannot be a critic without some level of connoisseurship (Eisner, 1991, p 86). And as John Dewey pointed out in Art as Experience, criticism has at its end the re-education of perception (1934).
In all my years of teaching I’ve almost never observed how other teachers perform their work. A teacher working in the classroom with learners is not the same as a teacher working on a committee or on a grade level team, which I’ve seen plenty of. But Dr. Eisner says that to know what schools are like, their strengths and their weaknesses, we need to be able to see what occurs in them, and we need to be able to tell others what we have seen in ways that are vivid and insightful. We need to achieve a critic’s level of educational connoisseurship to recognize what counts, and we need to create a form of educational criticism to make what we see clear to those who have a stake in our schools (Eisner, 1991, p 22.)
Dr. Eisner goes on to say, “Raising [standardized] test scores might indeed be possible. But what, from an educational perspective, does it mean? Only by assessing the quality of teaching and the significance of the content being taught can we be in a position to make such judgments. This requires appraising education in ways akin to those in which critics appraise novels, films, poetry, and art. It requires judgment, and such judgments depend upon connoisseurship in the field in which the work is done (p 23).
Vladimir Nabokov observes,
“A lily is more real to a naturalist than it is to the ordinary person. But it is still more real to the botanist. And yet another stage of reality is reached with that botanist who is a specialist in lilies” (in Eisner, 1991, p 63).
Thus, the botanist who is a specialist looks at lilies differently and is more qualified to conduct inquiry about them than a person who has not conceptualized the vast repertoire of knowledge that is relevant to their domain. According to Miller (1956), only a subset of that knowledge is relevant to any particular problem. Experts and connoisseurs do not have to search through everything they know in order to find what is relevant; such an approach would overwhelm their working memory.
Experts have not only acquired knowledge, but are also good at retrieving the knowledge that is relevant to a particular task. In the language of cognitive scientists, experts’ knowledge is “conditionalized”—it includes a specification of the contexts in which it is useful (Simon, 1980; Glaser, 1992). Knowledge that is not conditionalized is often “inert” because it is not activated, even though it is relevant (Whitehead, 1929) (in Bransford et al, 2000). Thus, instructional technologists seek connoisseurship in the domains of learning and education.
Dynamics of learning. Computer environments can assist students with strategies that promote expertise (Lajoie & Derry, 1993). An issue that arises, though, is the conceptual understanding of the reciprocal influences among learner, tool, and learning environment. Assessment of the whole environment, not merely the effects of the tool as an isolated component, becomes critical.
The need to evaluate whole environments creates a second issue; finding the methodological means through which the changes in the environment can be documented and studied (Bransford et al, 2000). My response to the question above outlines a methodology for studying the whole cultural realm of teachers while they are in their workspace, thanks to the work of leaders in the field such as Jordan and Henderson (1995).
THE RESEARCH TEAM
I am excited and a little intimidated to be working with a team of professional researchers and Subject Matter Experts (SMEs). The expertise that I bring to this group derives from my love of research and from serendipitous events, but before I share those, my formal qualifications are: Master of Education state certified teacher for 29 years, English major and early childhood minor. That’s it—plus the coursework for my doctoral program.
The serendipity. I graduated from Logan High School at age 16 and married Don, the authentic cowboy of my dreams, in 1959. That was before the youth in our area had been admonished to wait until age 16 to even date. That summer I was called by my church to teach a Laurels class of young women, which I did with great trepidation for the next two years. I was teaching! But I was the one being taught. Each Tuesday evening I greeted my girls with my heart in my throat and my hands cold as ice. My young women and I grew and bonded. We learned. What they didn't realize, though, was that most of them were older than their "leader."
Twenty years later Don and I found ourselves with a total of six beautiful children, ages 18 down to 1. Don had encouraged me to take a writing class at Weber State College (now WSU), the first of many classes that led to a teaching career.
Locating “myself” in the literature. It’s been fun to discover the values of qualitative folks like Nel Noddings, who brings the quality of happiness into education, Harry Wolcott who “thinks in threes” and uses the branches of a large tree (instead of straight rows and columns) to represent the organization of qualitative research, and Dr. Eisner who is a defender of the student whose expertise lies in the metacognitive areas of music, dance, sports, or the visual arts. I’d never have found such treasures in the literature if someone hadn’t pointed the way.
Qualifications. I am a budding expert in a few small things, such as where to look or who to ask for guidance in the design of effective evaluation instruments and the selection of appropriate methodologies for research. I will always look for the expertise of the leaders in my field. For now I have the privilege of being mentored by my research team.
Limitations. We as a research team like to think of ourselves as a group of subject matter experts (SMEs) with access to best practices. One or more of us will always be a connoisseur and mentor in areas where others of us may be novices. If all are novices in regard to some aspect of the work, the abstract representations of knowledge we possess will transfer to help us chip away at solutions (Bransford et al, 2000).
Why I’m here. The mention of technology is very often pushed to the background of those whom it serves, the human family. In 1990 my youngest daughter and I were walking through a poor neighborhood in Recife, Brazil on our way to a hardware store when we saw a young girl watching us. I later wrote in my journal, “A girl, six or seven years old, stood in the doorway of a little shack dressed in tattered rags. Her eyes met mine for a moment as we passed by. I’m sure that I gasped with astonishment because she made such an impression on me. I saw something in her glance that I can only describe as an impression of intelligence. We went on about our business, but I felt that we had passed near someone of profound importance."
Because of this type of experience, similar to the experiences of many others that I’ve heard of or read since that time, I’d like to join my area of expertise with other researchers and instructional designers to learn about and assist the amazing teachers of the world in weaving the threads of family and culture throughout globalized and localized curriculum. Our tools are technologies.
At this time I’m grateful for the fabulous opportunity to be guided by the connoisseurs and skilled critics of my graduation committee and for the great patience I see that all of this requires. Thank you.
Sunday, January 27, 2008
REFs #5
Bransford, J., Brown, A., & Cocking, R. (Eds.). (2000). How people learn: Brain, mind, experience, and school. Committee on Developments in the Science of Learning. Washington, DC: National Academy Press.
Dewey, J. (1934). Art as Experience. New York, Minton, Balch and Company.
Eisner, E. (1991). The Enlightened Eye: Qualitative Inquiry and the Enhancement of Educational Practice. Macmillan Publishing Company. New York.
Eisner, E.W. (1985). The Art of Educational Evaluation: A Personal View.Philadelphia,
PA: The Falmer Press.
Glaser, R. (1992). Expert knowledge and processes of thinking. Pp. 63-75 in Enhancing
Thinking Skills in the Sciences and Mathematics. D.F. Halpern, ed. Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.
Jordan, B., & Henderson, A. (1995). Interaction analysis: Foundations and practice. The
Journal of the Learning Sciences, 4(1), 39-103.
Lajoie, S., & Derry, S. (1993). Computers as cognitive tools. Hillsdale: Lawrence
Earlbaum Associates.
Miller, G. A. (1956). The magical number seven, plus or minus two. Some limits on our
capacity to process information. Psychological Review 63:81-87.
Simon, H. A. (1980). Problem solving and education. Pp. 81-96 in Problem Solving and
Education: Issues in Teaching and Research, D.T. Tuma and R. Reif, eds. Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.
Whitehead, A. N. (1929). The Aims of Education. New York: MacMillan.
Dewey, J. (1934). Art as Experience. New York, Minton, Balch and Company.
Eisner, E. (1991). The Enlightened Eye: Qualitative Inquiry and the Enhancement of Educational Practice. Macmillan Publishing Company. New York.
Eisner, E.W. (1985). The Art of Educational Evaluation: A Personal View.Philadelphia,
PA: The Falmer Press.
Glaser, R. (1992). Expert knowledge and processes of thinking. Pp. 63-75 in Enhancing
Thinking Skills in the Sciences and Mathematics. D.F. Halpern, ed. Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.
Jordan, B., & Henderson, A. (1995). Interaction analysis: Foundations and practice. The
Journal of the Learning Sciences, 4(1), 39-103.
Lajoie, S., & Derry, S. (1993). Computers as cognitive tools. Hillsdale: Lawrence
Earlbaum Associates.
Miller, G. A. (1956). The magical number seven, plus or minus two. Some limits on our
capacity to process information. Psychological Review 63:81-87.
Simon, H. A. (1980). Problem solving and education. Pp. 81-96 in Problem Solving and
Education: Issues in Teaching and Research, D.T. Tuma and R. Reif, eds. Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.
Whitehead, A. N. (1929). The Aims of Education. New York: MacMillan.
Thursday, January 10, 2008
WEBshop
It took two and a half hours to get to the University of Utah because of the SNOW, slick roads, stop-and-go traffic, and then an uncooperative parking lot attendant! But Jared Covili's UEN presentation on Webpage tools was worth the effort! Sheryl Hulmston was the only other student besides me who braved the storm, so we had the instructor all to ourselves!!! We learned about UEN's teacher's tools, Google Webpage Creator, and now Blogger! The 2nd day of class was cancelled, so Jared presented everything today and gave us his e-mail address for our questions as we would be working through the processes on our own tomorrow.
Purpose
Happy New Year! This blog iterates toward the development of mechanisms to help K-3 teachers facilitate school-family literacy. My next work tasks include passing comprehensive exams, dissertation work, and publishing (Web and otherwise), while I continue as a teacher's aide in three second grade classrooms.
Some Web tools that I already have may prove useful: my blog, My UEN page, and my Google Webpage Creator. I also have a Website with Globat and another with my School District. First I need to copyright some of my Interactive Home-Writing mechanisms with Creative Commons and then post them...
Some Web tools that I already have may prove useful: my blog, My UEN page, and my Google Webpage Creator. I also have a Website with Globat and another with my School District. First I need to copyright some of my Interactive Home-Writing mechanisms with Creative Commons and then post them...
Friday, July 08, 2005
Pedagogical agents in my area of interest
Technologies that Support Parents and Teachers
Writing WITH their Elementary Students
by Dorothy C. Little
In today’s push to integrate technology in schools, Larry Cuban (2001) emphasizes the preservation of real world values. If time spent online or in video games becomes an “escape” from the real world --if it isn’t adding strength, worth, and beauty to one’s real life, then it is probably time for one to get offline. Such a statement suggests an issue of time-management for users. It also challenges us to begin technology integration on the K-3 level from the perspective of real-world utility. We must design more and better computer environments to facilitate real goals, real living, and real enjoyment.
A Learning Context
“Real world,” from the standpoint of my topic, means each student’s unique cultural and family background. It means the daily life-stories or “family folklore” of the significant people that children reside with. For a student, it means enhancing his or her personal identity, self-efficacy, and quest for literacy through becoming better acquainted with his own cultural roots and then planning, drafting, revising and editing “family history”--whether it is tidbits of daily humor or a saga of serious adventure. For K-3 authors, such writing endeavors require collaboration between teachers, parents, and students. A password-protected Web site becomes the preferred contact point. Such strategic coming together of content from possibly diverse ethnic backgrounds lends an opportunity for teachers to create highly intriguing environments that are likely to spark family camaraderie. A culminating aspect of the proposed Writing strategy is for students at school to meet their family members online in an author’s environment cohabited by peers and their family members and perhaps by teachers. The environment, once refined, might be termed a “Massively Multi-learner Online Learning Environment (MMOLE). The planned environment may feature themed meeting places (a cave, pond, or patio) where parents and students may collaborate or visit using text messaging. A key feature of the site is a “Hall of Recognition” where student work is exhibited and visitor responses can be posted. This feature should become self-sustaining, with the agent available to guide students and parents in posting and viewing their own work.
An Agent’s Role
The agent environment is the entry path to both the MMOLE and the Hall of Recognition, and will feature a mentoring school principal. His tasks will be to act as a host to welcome both students and adults by their first names or pseudo names, to guide them to the location of their published works in the Hall of Recognition, and to offer tutoring through the writing process on any of the given assignments.
While the teacher, peers, and the families of peers may be present in the environment at any time and may interact by text messaging, the Principal agent will always be visible to each visitor on their own computer screens as if he were available to them exclusively to tutor or guide them in a personal mentoring way. The Principal agent would not be present in the MMOLE link.
How to evaluate the agent’s performance and students’ learning
The agent’s performance will be evaluated according to the perceptions of teachers, parents, and students with regard to his helpfulness.
Students’ learning will be evaluated by pre- and post- assessments of self-efficacy, reading achievement and attitude toward writing.
Differences will be measured between perceived sacrifices and perceived benefits of the writing treatment from the perspectives of parents and of teachers.
The treatment consists of a 7-month writing program derived from the
works of Donald Graves and of Brad Wilcox, modified by practicing teachers according to their students’ needs and in accordance with the Utah Core Curriculum Guide.
Writing WITH their Elementary Students
by Dorothy C. Little
In today’s push to integrate technology in schools, Larry Cuban (2001) emphasizes the preservation of real world values. If time spent online or in video games becomes an “escape” from the real world --if it isn’t adding strength, worth, and beauty to one’s real life, then it is probably time for one to get offline. Such a statement suggests an issue of time-management for users. It also challenges us to begin technology integration on the K-3 level from the perspective of real-world utility. We must design more and better computer environments to facilitate real goals, real living, and real enjoyment.
A Learning Context
“Real world,” from the standpoint of my topic, means each student’s unique cultural and family background. It means the daily life-stories or “family folklore” of the significant people that children reside with. For a student, it means enhancing his or her personal identity, self-efficacy, and quest for literacy through becoming better acquainted with his own cultural roots and then planning, drafting, revising and editing “family history”--whether it is tidbits of daily humor or a saga of serious adventure. For K-3 authors, such writing endeavors require collaboration between teachers, parents, and students. A password-protected Web site becomes the preferred contact point. Such strategic coming together of content from possibly diverse ethnic backgrounds lends an opportunity for teachers to create highly intriguing environments that are likely to spark family camaraderie. A culminating aspect of the proposed Writing strategy is for students at school to meet their family members online in an author’s environment cohabited by peers and their family members and perhaps by teachers. The environment, once refined, might be termed a “Massively Multi-learner Online Learning Environment (MMOLE). The planned environment may feature themed meeting places (a cave, pond, or patio) where parents and students may collaborate or visit using text messaging. A key feature of the site is a “Hall of Recognition” where student work is exhibited and visitor responses can be posted. This feature should become self-sustaining, with the agent available to guide students and parents in posting and viewing their own work.
An Agent’s Role
The agent environment is the entry path to both the MMOLE and the Hall of Recognition, and will feature a mentoring school principal. His tasks will be to act as a host to welcome both students and adults by their first names or pseudo names, to guide them to the location of their published works in the Hall of Recognition, and to offer tutoring through the writing process on any of the given assignments.
While the teacher, peers, and the families of peers may be present in the environment at any time and may interact by text messaging, the Principal agent will always be visible to each visitor on their own computer screens as if he were available to them exclusively to tutor or guide them in a personal mentoring way. The Principal agent would not be present in the MMOLE link.
How to evaluate the agent’s performance and students’ learning
The agent’s performance will be evaluated according to the perceptions of teachers, parents, and students with regard to his helpfulness.
Students’ learning will be evaluated by pre- and post- assessments of self-efficacy, reading achievement and attitude toward writing.
Differences will be measured between perceived sacrifices and perceived benefits of the writing treatment from the perspectives of parents and of teachers.
The treatment consists of a 7-month writing program derived from the
works of Donald Graves and of Brad Wilcox, modified by practicing teachers according to their students’ needs and in accordance with the Utah Core Curriculum Guide.
Monday, February 14, 2005
School-Family Literacy and Houle's Ideology: a study
EDUCATIONAL NEED
A student writer’s first audience is usually his teacher. The ‘catch-22’ is that if one teacher reads everything that all of his or her students write, the students will not be writing nearly enough to satisfy core curriculum requirements! Thus, teachers are often faced with unmanageable stacks of students’ writing in need of editing and receiving feedback. This sheer volume of the editing and feedback task often forces teachers to short-cut through core steps of the writing process; hence “passing on” problems to the next grade level and cutting short the learner’s trajectories that would have resulted from earlier achievement.
This study subscribes to Cyril O. Houle’s assumption that “A generalized educational design should be used to strengthen (not replace) the values that arise from profound belief, dedication, or creativeness.” Specifically, it hypothesizes that school-home partnerships with the parents of students from inner-city schools where there is a larger percentage of multicultural and low-income families will result in literacy achievement similar to the amount of achievement that has been observed in a rural school class of second graders who are mostly affluent Caucasian students from intact families. This is not to say that scores will be comparable between urban and rural students, but more importantly, that similar growth and motivation will be observed over time. This hypothesis is stated with its sub-questions on page 6.
Houle’s approach to adult education is to present a system of educational design that may have relevance to education at any age of life but that has grown specifically out of an analysis of the organized and purposeful learning activities of men and women. The learning addressed in this study stems from a proposed partnership between adults and their children. It becomes clear that understanding in the field of adult learning is needed by elementary teachers to successfully orchestrate all-inclusive school-home partnerships.
A pilot test was conducted in a rural Utah elementary school using the proposed experimental writing program. It has been determined that a majority of the parents were favorably receptive and responsive to the rubric that accompanied their child’s writing homework. Only one or two students needed additional support from the teacher to complete their assignments. The resultant writings were celebrated at “Author’s Chair” and then bound into Traveling Books to be checked out by students for “Shared Reading Experiences” with their families. The first students to complete assignments provided significant motivation for the others to prepare their assignments and to sign up for Author’s Chair. The nature of each writing project requires that no child be left out of a Traveling Book. At the end of the year, the well-worn Traveling Books were disassembled and then students compiled their stories into personal books to keep. The process could be described by a teacher as “challenging during the first two months but self-sustaining and exciting during the entire remaining seven months of the year…” providing expanded “teacher bandwidth” without unmanageable stacks of students’ writing relentlessly begging for audience and feedback. An important key to success with the school-home partnership program seemed to stem from the fact that students achieved mastery of the writing process, motivation to write, and collaboration skills within the classroom prior to collaborating with their parents on home-writing projects.
How have second grade teachers traditionally increased “teacher bandwidth?” Volunteer parents have often been helpful in classrooms. School-home partnerships have been tried with some success, but teachers are reluctant to implement them since in-depth work with all parents might increase a teacher’s workload significantly. Many parents may lack writing skills themselves. They may speak different languages or they may not value literacy skills in the first place. They may simply not understand about the teacher’s approach with their child nor may they care.
Houle’s view of adult learners is that “enunciation by writers and lecturers of the values of adult education is not sufficient to make most men and women seek to achieve them (The Design of Education, p. 3, italics added.)” Neither is the annual back-to-school-night “pep-talk” adequate to involve parents in meaningful writing partnerships with schools.
HYPOTHESES
Will eagerness to share personal background and culture in collaborative groups be manifested in writings by students? Will such attitudes cause literacy achievement scores to rise? Will students’ scores show progression at comparable rates between rural and urban schools?
This study hypothesizes that there is no significant difference between the achievement of second grade students in urban schools that employ school-home partnerships for writing and the achievement of second grade students in rural schools that employ school-home partnerships for writing, where all participating teachers are managing school-home partnerships based on the same foundational program.
Measurements will be taken on the following hypotheses:
1. No significant difference will be measured between the writing progress of urban students and the writing progress of rural students, as measured by a mid-year test, a post-test, and a teacher’s survey.
2. No significant difference in the degree of parent participation in the school-home partnership will be measured between urban and rural schools.
3. No significant difference in the perceived degree of “teacher bandwidth” will be measured between urban and rural schools in teacher surveys.
4. No significant difference will be measured between achievement of students who completed the experimental instruction and control students from randomly selected second grade classrooms who were not involved with the experiment in a follow-up quiz.
METHODS
Experimental participants for this study are limited to second grade teachers from a sample of Utah elementary schools in both inner-city and rural areas. The participating teachers in turn will implicate the families of their students in the study. Control groups of both inner-city and rural school second grades may not be invited to participate until the final weeks of the study when they will be invited to take the student follow-up quiz, with their accompanying informed consent forms signed by parents.
Each participating teacher with his or her students and their parents will be considered a “group” within the experiment. Each will receive a designation as “urban” or “rural” based on the location of the school where they are located. To qualify as a participant group, the teacher and a parent or guardian for each and every student within the group must sign an informed consent notice.
Timing:
The experiment should progress through about seven months of a normal school year, culminating about two months before school is dismissed for summer vacation. At that time all follow-up questionnaires and interviews will be completed, with simple post-tests being administered to students of both control and experimental groups.
During the first eight weeks of the experiment, usually beginning in mid-September, one hour per week of classroom time will be required for presenting the experimental instruction. The weekly one-hour instruction should usually replace a portion of the teacher’s traditional literacy block.
The most visible components of the experimental instruction include:
1. Published biographies derived from each student-author’s interview with a classmate and then working through the six steps of the writing process
2. Several Traveling Books, published together with peers and teacher to be checked out overnight by students and responded to by parents
3. Author’s Chair- Celebrations that involve author’s performance and audience’s critical listening for the purpose of offering feedback
4. Additional Traveling Books, compiled from home-writing assignments that have been performed at Author’s Chair
5. Teacher-conferencing with student-authors about their work
Participation in the study requires that the experimental instruction be completed within logical time constraints as outlined. An extra month is allowed for completion of the first eight weeks’ activities due to the importance of this foundational instruction, and the probability of unplanned time constraints. During the fourth or fifth month of the instruction (usually January), parents are automatically implicated in a simple school-home partnership to help their child complete two to five significant home-writing projects based on their cultural backgrounds and experiences.
Measures to be employed:
The experimental instruction, which is the independent variable, will be measured by:
1. a Likert scale survey from each participating teacher
a. Quantitative questions on the survey will allow teachers to summarize the scores from their students’ mid-year and follow-up quizzes in the categories of male and female
b. Qualitative questions to reflect the teacher’s perceptions will be quantified and measured on the same five-point Likert scale
c. Two qualitative questions will allow teachers to submit their observations concerning the seven-months of experimental instruction
d. A comparison of academic and attitudinal levels between experimental students and control students in rural and in urban schools will be measured by a follow-up quiz.
The degree of parent participation in the school-home partnership program will be documented using two measures:
1. If a student turns in an acceptable home-writing assignment on time, his or her parent will be reported as “participating” on the teacher’s survey.
2. A survey will be sent home with students for parents to indicate their impressions regarding the home-writing assignments.
Teacher’s perceived degree of “bandwidth” during phases of the instruction will be measured by two questions on the teacher’s survey.
DATA ANALYSIS
Quantitatively, an analysis of variance will be used to compare scores between urban and rural schools on the parent survey, teacher survey, and student quiz.
An analysis of variance will be used to compare scores between control and experimental groups on the follow-up quiz.
Qualitatively, comments from parents and teachers will be categorized for interpretation.
DISCUSSION:
Research has already verified that the components of this instruction are highly effective for academic achievement, yet usability issues and suggested improvements may become evident. The heavier question is not whether the experimental instruction conforms to instructional principles, but whether already over-worked teachers are likely to implement this type of instruction. The teacher’s survey may yield important data about “teacher bandwidth,” teachers who work with students in urban schools may encounter problems that the rural pilot study did not identify, and the parent survey will come from the mindset of adult learners and may provide guidance for involving them more effectively and efficiently in home-writing partnerships with their children.
As this causal experimental study unfolds, so does the underlying assumption that ethnicity and culture lie at the heart of meaning making and cognition. Important sub-questions are sure to emerge that are beyond its scope. For example, how might qualified volunteers be recruited to assist ESL students with bilingual writings? What translating policies might apply? How might teachers support parents in their home-writing partnerships? How might teachers support individual students whose parents opt out of their partnerships? What support do teachers need to manage home-partnerships in urban schools? And last but not least…how might more “academic mileage” be derived from any single writing project… thus maintaining critical teacher bandwidth?
Computers are not considered as part of this study, yet other sub-questions may emerge that are computer-related for future investigation. For example, in what ways might the Internet enhance the management of school-home partnerships? How might Internet safety for young children be addressed in establishing self-sustaining online environments for students to engage in peer collaborations and publications? What environments might allow feedback from parents, teachers and/or peer students? How might such environments be fine-tuned to the specialized needs of pre-keyboarding authors?
The strategies and dynamics outlined for this experiment represent vital classroom prerequisites to a student’s later online learning. But that is another study. Houle’s model for organizing Categories of Educational Design Situations provides a useful tool for considering this list of questions about computer-mediated instruction in online environments for pre-keyboarding children. Larger numbers of students may be associated personally with adult members of their learning communities, which again brings into play the issue of Internet safety for children.
As computer mediated instruction hovers on the horizon for the very young, one wonders how to adequately prepare children for online success. This study assumes that a student who establishes a sense of personal identity, values, and cultural pride prior to online experiences will be strengthened against deceptive online involvements. The extent to which a student is able to represent his or her true identity online…whether in a fantasy environment or not…theoretically will determine the level of online credibility with which his or her presence becomes associated.
As Houle so aptly stated, education should strengthen (not replace) the values that arise from profound belief, dedication, or creativeness. The results of this study may guide future decisions to design elementary instruction that draws on family and culture for literacy achievement in the writing process while at the same time increasing …for lack of better words…teacher bandwidth!
A student writer’s first audience is usually his teacher. The ‘catch-22’ is that if one teacher reads everything that all of his or her students write, the students will not be writing nearly enough to satisfy core curriculum requirements! Thus, teachers are often faced with unmanageable stacks of students’ writing in need of editing and receiving feedback. This sheer volume of the editing and feedback task often forces teachers to short-cut through core steps of the writing process; hence “passing on” problems to the next grade level and cutting short the learner’s trajectories that would have resulted from earlier achievement.
This study subscribes to Cyril O. Houle’s assumption that “A generalized educational design should be used to strengthen (not replace) the values that arise from profound belief, dedication, or creativeness.” Specifically, it hypothesizes that school-home partnerships with the parents of students from inner-city schools where there is a larger percentage of multicultural and low-income families will result in literacy achievement similar to the amount of achievement that has been observed in a rural school class of second graders who are mostly affluent Caucasian students from intact families. This is not to say that scores will be comparable between urban and rural students, but more importantly, that similar growth and motivation will be observed over time. This hypothesis is stated with its sub-questions on page 6.
Houle’s approach to adult education is to present a system of educational design that may have relevance to education at any age of life but that has grown specifically out of an analysis of the organized and purposeful learning activities of men and women. The learning addressed in this study stems from a proposed partnership between adults and their children. It becomes clear that understanding in the field of adult learning is needed by elementary teachers to successfully orchestrate all-inclusive school-home partnerships.
A pilot test was conducted in a rural Utah elementary school using the proposed experimental writing program. It has been determined that a majority of the parents were favorably receptive and responsive to the rubric that accompanied their child’s writing homework. Only one or two students needed additional support from the teacher to complete their assignments. The resultant writings were celebrated at “Author’s Chair” and then bound into Traveling Books to be checked out by students for “Shared Reading Experiences” with their families. The first students to complete assignments provided significant motivation for the others to prepare their assignments and to sign up for Author’s Chair. The nature of each writing project requires that no child be left out of a Traveling Book. At the end of the year, the well-worn Traveling Books were disassembled and then students compiled their stories into personal books to keep. The process could be described by a teacher as “challenging during the first two months but self-sustaining and exciting during the entire remaining seven months of the year…” providing expanded “teacher bandwidth” without unmanageable stacks of students’ writing relentlessly begging for audience and feedback. An important key to success with the school-home partnership program seemed to stem from the fact that students achieved mastery of the writing process, motivation to write, and collaboration skills within the classroom prior to collaborating with their parents on home-writing projects.
How have second grade teachers traditionally increased “teacher bandwidth?” Volunteer parents have often been helpful in classrooms. School-home partnerships have been tried with some success, but teachers are reluctant to implement them since in-depth work with all parents might increase a teacher’s workload significantly. Many parents may lack writing skills themselves. They may speak different languages or they may not value literacy skills in the first place. They may simply not understand about the teacher’s approach with their child nor may they care.
Houle’s view of adult learners is that “enunciation by writers and lecturers of the values of adult education is not sufficient to make most men and women seek to achieve them (The Design of Education, p. 3, italics added.)” Neither is the annual back-to-school-night “pep-talk” adequate to involve parents in meaningful writing partnerships with schools.
HYPOTHESES
Will eagerness to share personal background and culture in collaborative groups be manifested in writings by students? Will such attitudes cause literacy achievement scores to rise? Will students’ scores show progression at comparable rates between rural and urban schools?
This study hypothesizes that there is no significant difference between the achievement of second grade students in urban schools that employ school-home partnerships for writing and the achievement of second grade students in rural schools that employ school-home partnerships for writing, where all participating teachers are managing school-home partnerships based on the same foundational program.
Measurements will be taken on the following hypotheses:
1. No significant difference will be measured between the writing progress of urban students and the writing progress of rural students, as measured by a mid-year test, a post-test, and a teacher’s survey.
2. No significant difference in the degree of parent participation in the school-home partnership will be measured between urban and rural schools.
3. No significant difference in the perceived degree of “teacher bandwidth” will be measured between urban and rural schools in teacher surveys.
4. No significant difference will be measured between achievement of students who completed the experimental instruction and control students from randomly selected second grade classrooms who were not involved with the experiment in a follow-up quiz.
METHODS
Experimental participants for this study are limited to second grade teachers from a sample of Utah elementary schools in both inner-city and rural areas. The participating teachers in turn will implicate the families of their students in the study. Control groups of both inner-city and rural school second grades may not be invited to participate until the final weeks of the study when they will be invited to take the student follow-up quiz, with their accompanying informed consent forms signed by parents.
Each participating teacher with his or her students and their parents will be considered a “group” within the experiment. Each will receive a designation as “urban” or “rural” based on the location of the school where they are located. To qualify as a participant group, the teacher and a parent or guardian for each and every student within the group must sign an informed consent notice.
Timing:
The experiment should progress through about seven months of a normal school year, culminating about two months before school is dismissed for summer vacation. At that time all follow-up questionnaires and interviews will be completed, with simple post-tests being administered to students of both control and experimental groups.
During the first eight weeks of the experiment, usually beginning in mid-September, one hour per week of classroom time will be required for presenting the experimental instruction. The weekly one-hour instruction should usually replace a portion of the teacher’s traditional literacy block.
The most visible components of the experimental instruction include:
1. Published biographies derived from each student-author’s interview with a classmate and then working through the six steps of the writing process
2. Several Traveling Books, published together with peers and teacher to be checked out overnight by students and responded to by parents
3. Author’s Chair- Celebrations that involve author’s performance and audience’s critical listening for the purpose of offering feedback
4. Additional Traveling Books, compiled from home-writing assignments that have been performed at Author’s Chair
5. Teacher-conferencing with student-authors about their work
Participation in the study requires that the experimental instruction be completed within logical time constraints as outlined. An extra month is allowed for completion of the first eight weeks’ activities due to the importance of this foundational instruction, and the probability of unplanned time constraints. During the fourth or fifth month of the instruction (usually January), parents are automatically implicated in a simple school-home partnership to help their child complete two to five significant home-writing projects based on their cultural backgrounds and experiences.
Measures to be employed:
The experimental instruction, which is the independent variable, will be measured by:
1. a Likert scale survey from each participating teacher
a. Quantitative questions on the survey will allow teachers to summarize the scores from their students’ mid-year and follow-up quizzes in the categories of male and female
b. Qualitative questions to reflect the teacher’s perceptions will be quantified and measured on the same five-point Likert scale
c. Two qualitative questions will allow teachers to submit their observations concerning the seven-months of experimental instruction
d. A comparison of academic and attitudinal levels between experimental students and control students in rural and in urban schools will be measured by a follow-up quiz.
The degree of parent participation in the school-home partnership program will be documented using two measures:
1. If a student turns in an acceptable home-writing assignment on time, his or her parent will be reported as “participating” on the teacher’s survey.
2. A survey will be sent home with students for parents to indicate their impressions regarding the home-writing assignments.
Teacher’s perceived degree of “bandwidth” during phases of the instruction will be measured by two questions on the teacher’s survey.
DATA ANALYSIS
Quantitatively, an analysis of variance will be used to compare scores between urban and rural schools on the parent survey, teacher survey, and student quiz.
An analysis of variance will be used to compare scores between control and experimental groups on the follow-up quiz.
Qualitatively, comments from parents and teachers will be categorized for interpretation.
DISCUSSION:
Research has already verified that the components of this instruction are highly effective for academic achievement, yet usability issues and suggested improvements may become evident. The heavier question is not whether the experimental instruction conforms to instructional principles, but whether already over-worked teachers are likely to implement this type of instruction. The teacher’s survey may yield important data about “teacher bandwidth,” teachers who work with students in urban schools may encounter problems that the rural pilot study did not identify, and the parent survey will come from the mindset of adult learners and may provide guidance for involving them more effectively and efficiently in home-writing partnerships with their children.
As this causal experimental study unfolds, so does the underlying assumption that ethnicity and culture lie at the heart of meaning making and cognition. Important sub-questions are sure to emerge that are beyond its scope. For example, how might qualified volunteers be recruited to assist ESL students with bilingual writings? What translating policies might apply? How might teachers support parents in their home-writing partnerships? How might teachers support individual students whose parents opt out of their partnerships? What support do teachers need to manage home-partnerships in urban schools? And last but not least…how might more “academic mileage” be derived from any single writing project… thus maintaining critical teacher bandwidth?
Computers are not considered as part of this study, yet other sub-questions may emerge that are computer-related for future investigation. For example, in what ways might the Internet enhance the management of school-home partnerships? How might Internet safety for young children be addressed in establishing self-sustaining online environments for students to engage in peer collaborations and publications? What environments might allow feedback from parents, teachers and/or peer students? How might such environments be fine-tuned to the specialized needs of pre-keyboarding authors?
The strategies and dynamics outlined for this experiment represent vital classroom prerequisites to a student’s later online learning. But that is another study. Houle’s model for organizing Categories of Educational Design Situations provides a useful tool for considering this list of questions about computer-mediated instruction in online environments for pre-keyboarding children. Larger numbers of students may be associated personally with adult members of their learning communities, which again brings into play the issue of Internet safety for children.
As computer mediated instruction hovers on the horizon for the very young, one wonders how to adequately prepare children for online success. This study assumes that a student who establishes a sense of personal identity, values, and cultural pride prior to online experiences will be strengthened against deceptive online involvements. The extent to which a student is able to represent his or her true identity online…whether in a fantasy environment or not…theoretically will determine the level of online credibility with which his or her presence becomes associated.
As Houle so aptly stated, education should strengthen (not replace) the values that arise from profound belief, dedication, or creativeness. The results of this study may guide future decisions to design elementary instruction that draws on family and culture for literacy achievement in the writing process while at the same time increasing …for lack of better words…teacher bandwidth!
Saturday, January 29, 2005
SUPERIORITY- by Arthur C. Clarke
This 1951 science fiction story is about an army that was defeated by an inferior army. It chronicles the mistakes that the superior army made that caused them to lose the war. What is Clarke saying in his science fiction “Superior”?
The superior army had in its possession a good arsenal of existing weapons that had been refined over several generations. Norden, the new Chief of the Research Staff and an aggressive theoretical scientist, accused the existing staff of devoting itself to “perfecting old weapons instead of developing new ones.” Norden replaced some of the older scientists with young men. New technology was introduced immediately, based on Norden’s theoretical promises.
Clark’s story encompassed several issues. Most glaring was the fact that Norden wanted to replace the army’s “imperfect old weapons” with his dream machines, and then succeeded in convincing others to pursue his plans. However, Norden and his staff failed to accurately consider constraints of time and resources, standardization of new technology with existing technology, usability, and reliability.
Time and resource constraints were not planned for, nor were the limitations of new technologies. Instead, these issues were often encountered during critical maneuvers and with heavy penalties. For example, it was discovered after-the-fact that Norden's Sphere of Annihilation disintegrated itself along with its target.
Standardization was overlooked when a new class of torpedo had to be designed to carry the new “Sphere of Annihilation” that theoretically should have been carried on existing torpedoes.
Usability was not considered when the “Battle Analyser” replaced members of the Operations Staff, later requiring a team of five hundred technicians to maintain each Analyser... and a separate liner to follow along after each battleship to house technicians while they were off-duty.
Unreliability of the “Exponential Field” also became apparent during the heat of battle, causing demoralization of the army and giving ultimate advantage to the enemy.
The human element was also overlooked, as evidenced by replacing experienced staff members with inexperienced ones, and by the confusion, nervous breakdowns and chaos that resulted from trying to force men into the role of trained technicians to maintain and operate the Battle Analyser.
What is Clarke saying in his science fiction “Superior”? His perceptive story leads us through a few possible consequences of jumping directly from theory into the implementation of new technologies. One must wonder how Arthur Clarke could imagine with such accuracy!
The superior army had in its possession a good arsenal of existing weapons that had been refined over several generations. Norden, the new Chief of the Research Staff and an aggressive theoretical scientist, accused the existing staff of devoting itself to “perfecting old weapons instead of developing new ones.” Norden replaced some of the older scientists with young men. New technology was introduced immediately, based on Norden’s theoretical promises.
Clark’s story encompassed several issues. Most glaring was the fact that Norden wanted to replace the army’s “imperfect old weapons” with his dream machines, and then succeeded in convincing others to pursue his plans. However, Norden and his staff failed to accurately consider constraints of time and resources, standardization of new technology with existing technology, usability, and reliability.
Time and resource constraints were not planned for, nor were the limitations of new technologies. Instead, these issues were often encountered during critical maneuvers and with heavy penalties. For example, it was discovered after-the-fact that Norden's Sphere of Annihilation disintegrated itself along with its target.
Standardization was overlooked when a new class of torpedo had to be designed to carry the new “Sphere of Annihilation” that theoretically should have been carried on existing torpedoes.
Usability was not considered when the “Battle Analyser” replaced members of the Operations Staff, later requiring a team of five hundred technicians to maintain each Analyser... and a separate liner to follow along after each battleship to house technicians while they were off-duty.
Unreliability of the “Exponential Field” also became apparent during the heat of battle, causing demoralization of the army and giving ultimate advantage to the enemy.
The human element was also overlooked, as evidenced by replacing experienced staff members with inexperienced ones, and by the confusion, nervous breakdowns and chaos that resulted from trying to force men into the role of trained technicians to maintain and operate the Battle Analyser.
What is Clarke saying in his science fiction “Superior”? His perceptive story leads us through a few possible consequences of jumping directly from theory into the implementation of new technologies. One must wonder how Arthur Clarke could imagine with such accuracy!
* * *
“SUPERIORITY” was first published in The Magazine of Science Fiction and Fantasy, Aug., 1951, Collected in Expedition to Earth
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
