This paper explores the role of elementary schools in preparing children for technology-enhanced lives. A recent Wiley article entitled How Technology Will Destroy Schools (2004) forecasts the demise of education as we know it. Dave states, “Technology will (likely) destroy a lot of what elementary schools currently do.” Other social institutions such as family and government are also reportedly failing to meet individual needs.
What academic skill does a person need for playing massively multi-player online games (MMOGs)? Typically little is required beyond basic computer navigational savvy. But a notion persists that MMOLEs (Online Learning Environments) present a greater challenge because of their educational nature. What "real-world" pre-requisite common ground would peers in MMOLEs want to share that would facilitate their aggrigation online?
While I mulled over Gagné’s pre-requisites for learning, one condition loomed in my mind. One’s sense of identity or the coming to terms with one’s values, culture, and family background seemed suddenly to be a most important consideration. First of all, going online with a wishy-washy sense of identity would be a marked handicap to one attempting to collaborate with people who had already defined themselves.
Pride in one’s culture and self-worth should begin at home. Later, elementary school becomes an ideal social arena to celebrate cultural stories through parent-partnerships, shared readings, author’s chair, music, and other real-world, live-mentoring literacy activities.
Everyone has family histories! In my 28 years of elementary teaching I’ve never met a child who didn’t enjoy having his or her personalized cultural stories shared when given appropriate entry paths for sharing them. As a child’s identity and values become clearer, s/he will need real-world practice to learn skills to represent them with non-identifiable titles that can later be used as online identities or nicknames.
While puzzling over the “braining” of layers of human interface design that might interplay during natural aggregation of self-organizing MMOLEs, it seems apparent that foundational principles should begin with each person’s early need to have and to hold a living, breathing mentor. Early literacy falls within this earliest realm of parenting with its trajectories extending throughout life. A recent study by Hart and Risley, “The Early Catastrophe: The 30 Million Word Gap by Age 3,” points out that the majority of parents need support in their homes with literacy. The conclusion of the study states, “…the risk to our nation and its children…makes intervention more urgent than ever.”
Many of today’s children spend countless hours at Playstation II, Nintendo, and other video games while parents remain glued to their computer screens. Certainly some vital principles of child development and literacy are missing, yet society excuses itself by ridiculing “family” and those ‘naïve’ individuals who still cling to family values. But this trend against society’s institutions contradicts the open exhibition of family bonds that occurs during times of war and tragedy.
If given an entry path to consider the reality of one’s cultural history and background, most learners rank their families at the very top of their most valued assets. Why is that? I argue that despite society’s current state of denial, culture and family lie at the very heart of who we are. I base my argument on Maslow’s theory that one’s early childhood is foundational to his or her subsequent sense of identity and level of achievement.
In my experience as a young mother struggling with the problems of parenting, and later as an elementary teacher mentoring students, my problems often caused me to reflect on “What my mother might have done.” I recalled things that I had seen our mother do. While remembering subtle messages from her literature and art, more importantly I remembered her patient support, soft voice, light-handed control, and her example. Those impressions were profound. The way my parents raised me played a major role in the way that I helped to raise our own children. Our idiosyncrasies are apparent in the way that our children are raising their children. While some family behaviors may be dysfunctional for learning, mentors can draw cultural pride from all family roots to facilitate learning. These are the roots that I believe provide strength for the online learner.
Merrill’s First Principles of Instruction emphasize the need for real-world learning experiences. Merrill claims that Learners are facilitated when:
1. Learners are engaged in solving real-world problems.
2. Existing knowledge is activated as a foundation for new knowledge.
3. New knowledge is demonstrated to the learner.
4. New knowledge is applied by the learner.
5. New knowledge is integrated into the learner’s world.
I remember a powerful example of how a mentor, my mother, facilitated learning for my younger brother, Stan, when he lost his five-dollar bill and all of us tried to help him find it. After awhile Stan sensed the futility of a random search. Our mother supported him through purposeful steps similar to Merrill’s First Principles: She helped Stan say a prayer (he stated his problem), and then she helped him recall where he had last seen the bill. After his sketchy hypothesis, she laid a bed sheet on the back lawn and helped him dump the trash can onto it. Dumping the trash may have been her hunch or her setup, but she shushed me to silence when I spotted the five-dollar bill in the heap of trash. She demonstrated for Stan how to sort through the trash while Stan gingerly applied the sorting skill and consequently discovered the bill for himself. The lesson was complete. Through many such learning episodes, we gained mental models applicable to real-world and on-line problem-solving.
There is plenty of reason to believe that families, supported by elementary schools, are still vital training grounds for future online behavior. Schools may:
1-Support parents with early childhood literacy
2-Accelerate literacy development in the early grades
3-Enhance identity clarification through family history and personalized cultural activities, aided by parent-partnerships
4-Provide safety education for the Internet
5-Provide time and resource management education
6-Practice how to represent ones’ identity online without disclosing personal information
7-Establish real-world learning communities similar to on-line communities, complete with feedback capabilities from parents or peers
8-Teach social and collaborative skills
9-Teach online etiquette
10-Teach keyboarding, computer navigational skills, and basic programming of computer simulations
Yes, exciting questions abound! The notion that child development and early literacy should be pre-requisite to MMOLEs and improved MMOG environments must be studied and verified. Ways that schools and government might support parents with early literacy development and online readiness must be probed.
And, who is qualified enough to design online environments or entry paths leading to self-organizing environments that our precious children will enter… with what guidelines? How might learners qualify to gain empowerment to aggregate, collaborate, and govern within their communities? How will new MMOLEs rate in usability studies? How is critical mass achieved? How are self-sustaining intrinsic controls for normalcy reached? How is safety achieved?
Today millions of people from fascinating cultural backgrounds engage themselves daily in online communities…real communities of real people investing billions of hours online…with limited self-concept and literacy skills. Children spend increasing amounts of time playing video and MMOGs where they engage in mindless interactions. Much remains unknown about managing such powerful technological tools for the enhancement of the human race, but manage it we must because the tidal wave has already hit nearly every aspect of our lives and continues to rise.
Technology is not likely to recede with the ebb tide. It appears that humanity could either drown in undercurrents of the fruits of illiteracy that seem to proliferate online, or else the human family will rise to exhilarating new levels very quickly…
…Which causes me to dream that our children may gain high school credit online in something like a “Lands of Literature” MMOLE with obstacle-ridden topic areas, infestations of problems that require the application of mental models to solve them, sign-up boards for study teams, online bookstores, banks for credit caches, training grounds just outside the gym, assessment areas, a publishing site just beyond collaborative edit-baskets, a performing arts auditorium just after the audition and rehearsal studios…and LOTS of friends to locate and meet in "public chat caves” or “chat lagoons” between sessions.
But whoa…I’m not ready yet to turn my kids loose on the Net. The impact that computer technology has on the human race must not be left solely in the hands of money-minded software developers. Guidelines and support are needed…quickly.
Friday, December 31, 2004
Saturday, December 11, 2004
FIRST SLIME-MOLD SCREENSHOT
Slime creatures are sniffing out possible social acceptance in this Netlogo view.
SECOND SLIME-MOLD SCREENSHOT
Cyclic, aggrigated communities of Slime creatures are enjoying social acceptance in their self-sustaining clusters.
THIRD SLIME-MOLD SCREENSHOT
With a slightly increased 'sniff threshold, 150 Slime creatures are aggrigating on top of each other!
NO ONE OF US IS AS SMART AS ALL OF US!
My closing remarks are still to come. They must simmer a few more days before I blog them; today’s blog is the completion of last week’s work.
The self-organizing aggregation of slime mold can be leveraged. So can social software community environments. But by whom? Who sets the paremeters for flocking? For aggregating? For attaining critical mass?
As an example of how aggregated information can begin to evolve, my first screenshots failed to capture the turtles in the Netlogo window. So I asked Curt how HE did it. Say! What is that funny icon on his computer screen? Um, a screenshot utility? You say the link was in Dr. Wiley’s instructions? If all else fails, just… I know, I know.
Plus, Curt pointed out to me the photo icon on the toolbar at the top of the blog-posting window to upload photos. Um, I wonder how long that icon has been looking at me and wondering if I would ever notice it?
The first two Netlogo screenshots above show the aggregation behavior of slime-mold cells. They demonstrate how creatures can aggregate into clusters without the control of a “leader,” according to the variable settings of the invironment. I like to think that leaders are still important. But in such a setting there is not just one leader. Rather, leaders and mentors are emerging all the time, adjusting and improving the settings of the community.
It was by ignoring the leader’s instructions in the class assignment that I failed to post my Netlogo screenshots on time. Now look closely at the third screenshot. The aggregation behavior of Slime mold was leveraged with a .5-degree raise in ‘sniff threshold,’ resulting in all 150 participants piling on top of each other!
Where does the role of a ‘leader’ in a community begin and end? Who first provides the entry path, facilitates and leverages the cyber community to gain critical mass http://chickenarmpits.blogspot.com/, leaves shadowings of his or her ‘mentorship’ in pop-up windows or click-on ‘answer-buttons’ from which participants can network, assimilate, emulate, re-create, improve on, and launch itself as a self-organizing cyclic community of mentors?
No One of Us is as Smart as All of Us! So, if there are More of Us, what then might we accomplish?
The self-organizing aggregation of slime mold can be leveraged. So can social software community environments. But by whom? Who sets the paremeters for flocking? For aggregating? For attaining critical mass?
As an example of how aggregated information can begin to evolve, my first screenshots failed to capture the turtles in the Netlogo window. So I asked Curt how HE did it. Say! What is that funny icon on his computer screen? Um, a screenshot utility? You say the link was in Dr. Wiley’s instructions? If all else fails, just… I know, I know.
Plus, Curt pointed out to me the photo icon on the toolbar at the top of the blog-posting window to upload photos. Um, I wonder how long that icon has been looking at me and wondering if I would ever notice it?
The first two Netlogo screenshots above show the aggregation behavior of slime-mold cells. They demonstrate how creatures can aggregate into clusters without the control of a “leader,” according to the variable settings of the invironment. I like to think that leaders are still important. But in such a setting there is not just one leader. Rather, leaders and mentors are emerging all the time, adjusting and improving the settings of the community.
It was by ignoring the leader’s instructions in the class assignment that I failed to post my Netlogo screenshots on time. Now look closely at the third screenshot. The aggregation behavior of Slime mold was leveraged with a .5-degree raise in ‘sniff threshold,’ resulting in all 150 participants piling on top of each other!
Where does the role of a ‘leader’ in a community begin and end? Who first provides the entry path, facilitates and leverages the cyber community to gain critical mass http://chickenarmpits.blogspot.com/, leaves shadowings of his or her ‘mentorship’ in pop-up windows or click-on ‘answer-buttons’ from which participants can network, assimilate, emulate, re-create, improve on, and launch itself as a self-organizing cyclic community of mentors?
No One of Us is as Smart as All of Us! So, if there are More of Us, what then might we accomplish?
Sunday, December 05, 2004
OSOSS: Self Organization
This NetLogo stuff looks familiar! It reminds me of driving the old LOGO Turtle fifteen years ago by typing the simple or compound commands of L (__degrees), R __, FD (__ pixels) or BK __. My students used to get an “Ah-ha!” over the 360 degree turn…after which “90” and “45” R or L turns would become easy for them to understand. Thence fractions, angles, geometric shapes and the whole bit would fall into place!!!
Well, now it’s my turn to get the “Ah-ha! regarding aggregation behaviors and system self-organizers.” In the SLIME project, the use of PATCH-AHEAD, PATCH-LEFT-AND-AHEAD, and PATCH-RIGHT-AND-AHEAD primitives could be used to do the "sniffing". And, imagine, it still comes from LOGO. Um, … NETLOGO. Just look at how far we (uh, “They”) have come! New rules such as “alignment,” “separation,” “cohesion”, “wiggle,” “vision,” and “population” can be programmed in, and can even be set using slider bars! Additional variables can still be typed behind the Information Tab.
We see outward signs of the working of the laws of nature in social aggregation within our classrooms every day. I noticed that Ty resisted writing in his journal… until he decided that he could write “Dear Megan” and that Megan could later read and answer his messages. What rules guided Ty’s newfound exuberance for journal writing? Could he generalize those rules to the idea of writing “Dear Self” or “Dear World?”
I noticed that R.J. and Andy left their self-designed Indian costumes by the classroom door on their way to a Native American activity. Their peers were wearing expertly designed costumes, causing R.J. and Andy to feel that their homemade costumes were “stupid.” What rules of aggregation might have caused these social behaviors? Can the variables of social dynamics that we see within classrooms be programmed into NetLogo? Can we learn the best “default” settings for our students? Can students learn their own best default settings? How can these principles be applied outside of NetLogo? Hm.
NetLogo Screenshots will be posted as soon as I can figure out how to do it.
Well, now it’s my turn to get the “Ah-ha! regarding aggregation behaviors and system self-organizers.” In the SLIME project, the use of PATCH-AHEAD, PATCH-LEFT-AND-AHEAD, and PATCH-RIGHT-AND-AHEAD primitives could be used to do the "sniffing". And, imagine, it still comes from LOGO. Um, … NETLOGO. Just look at how far we (uh, “They”) have come! New rules such as “alignment,” “separation,” “cohesion”, “wiggle,” “vision,” and “population” can be programmed in, and can even be set using slider bars! Additional variables can still be typed behind the Information Tab.
We see outward signs of the working of the laws of nature in social aggregation within our classrooms every day. I noticed that Ty resisted writing in his journal… until he decided that he could write “Dear Megan” and that Megan could later read and answer his messages. What rules guided Ty’s newfound exuberance for journal writing? Could he generalize those rules to the idea of writing “Dear Self” or “Dear World?”
I noticed that R.J. and Andy left their self-designed Indian costumes by the classroom door on their way to a Native American activity. Their peers were wearing expertly designed costumes, causing R.J. and Andy to feel that their homemade costumes were “stupid.” What rules of aggregation might have caused these social behaviors? Can the variables of social dynamics that we see within classrooms be programmed into NetLogo? Can we learn the best “default” settings for our students? Can students learn their own best default settings? How can these principles be applied outside of NetLogo? Hm.
NetLogo Screenshots will be posted as soon as I can figure out how to do it.
Sunday, November 28, 2004
Friday, November 26, 2004
MORE GAMING
While studying Fanfiction a few weeks ago, Shelley opened my mind to the idea of “creating entry paths” for learners. As a teacher I’ve been creating entry paths for years. An entry path was opened with each snippet of literature. Whenever I placed a natural object in a student’s hand, another entry path emerged.
This week I went adventuring in the Lineage Land of Aden. The object of Lineage was to survive in a dark world by bludgeoning things to death before being killed by them. As engaging as Lineage became, it lacked entry paths that required much thinking skill on my part. The rules, if-thens, and gaming checks and balances had already been established. I had to play within the confines of set perimeters. I wanted more choice, more purpose.
I tried to envision MMOGs with thought-provoking entry paths such as a user-selected excerpt from literature, and with a choice of purpose. It already had options to meet up with teams or partners in the game-- and our cohort did demonstrate that safety, power, and belongingness can prevail when you use the buddy system!
Sometimes while alone in the game I felt slightly trapped. Such a feeling in a learning environment could motivate a learner to quit altogether.
In Lineage I looked like all the other female knights in the game. What options did I have? I researched. I noticed from the 'help' menu that exciting attributes, levels and rewards were in store for sustained players. Without a doubt, I decided that what would make the game rewarding would be to progress through the levels with other players, to interact, compete, tease and conquer TOGETHER. Whoa. How do I know these partners are who I really want to spend time with?
But I wanted to re-invent the game! I wanted to apply proven “entry paths” ... then use capabilities of the game to enable students to struggle toward their own goals and invent their own sequals, sort of like in Fanfiction... but better!
In a new kind of MMOG, what objectives could substitute for pointless wandering and bludgeoning for points? It seems that MMOGs with “just-in-time” pop-up windows and partner- or team-travel through compelling worlds filled with random ‘supporting evidences’ do hold great potential as training instruments.
Players, groups, or “committees” could earn capabilities not only to publish, but to actually dramatize and perform their findings for cyber-audiences! Or to sell their publications and perfomances for adena!
Sexuality being ever-present in the minds of players...since it comprises an aspect of our identities...begs for a higher level of defense in online environments. How can self-organizing environments provide safety from harrassment? Is such safety necessarily the service of a moderator? How long before individuals will be safe presenting themselves in MMOGs in context with their real identities?
How can programmers use advance organizers and schema signals to activate prior knowledge --REAL prior knowledge that originates with one's culture and family-- in MMOGs? Can real-life investments and consequences be represented? How can MMOGs align with all of Merrill’s First Principles of instruction?
Will purposeful entry paths provide choice and purpose in MMOGs?
WHO will do it? Who is doing it already?
This week I went adventuring in the Lineage Land of Aden. The object of Lineage was to survive in a dark world by bludgeoning things to death before being killed by them. As engaging as Lineage became, it lacked entry paths that required much thinking skill on my part. The rules, if-thens, and gaming checks and balances had already been established. I had to play within the confines of set perimeters. I wanted more choice, more purpose.
I tried to envision MMOGs with thought-provoking entry paths such as a user-selected excerpt from literature, and with a choice of purpose. It already had options to meet up with teams or partners in the game-- and our cohort did demonstrate that safety, power, and belongingness can prevail when you use the buddy system!
Sometimes while alone in the game I felt slightly trapped. Such a feeling in a learning environment could motivate a learner to quit altogether.
In Lineage I looked like all the other female knights in the game. What options did I have? I researched. I noticed from the 'help' menu that exciting attributes, levels and rewards were in store for sustained players. Without a doubt, I decided that what would make the game rewarding would be to progress through the levels with other players, to interact, compete, tease and conquer TOGETHER. Whoa. How do I know these partners are who I really want to spend time with?
But I wanted to re-invent the game! I wanted to apply proven “entry paths” ... then use capabilities of the game to enable students to struggle toward their own goals and invent their own sequals, sort of like in Fanfiction... but better!
In a new kind of MMOG, what objectives could substitute for pointless wandering and bludgeoning for points? It seems that MMOGs with “just-in-time” pop-up windows and partner- or team-travel through compelling worlds filled with random ‘supporting evidences’ do hold great potential as training instruments.
Players, groups, or “committees” could earn capabilities not only to publish, but to actually dramatize and perform their findings for cyber-audiences! Or to sell their publications and perfomances for adena!
Sexuality being ever-present in the minds of players...since it comprises an aspect of our identities...begs for a higher level of defense in online environments. How can self-organizing environments provide safety from harrassment? Is such safety necessarily the service of a moderator? How long before individuals will be safe presenting themselves in MMOGs in context with their real identities?
How can programmers use advance organizers and schema signals to activate prior knowledge --REAL prior knowledge that originates with one's culture and family-- in MMOGs? Can real-life investments and consequences be represented? How can MMOGs align with all of Merrill’s First Principles of instruction?
Will purposeful entry paths provide choice and purpose in MMOGs?
WHO will do it? Who is doing it already?
FAMILIES AND GAMING
What is this strange new cyberworld that our growing-up children must face…that we must face? Spending 12-16 hours in the massively multi-player online (MMO) game of Lineage was a course requirement for Dr. Wiley’s #7150 class at USU. It was the only way that I was ever likely to get into such a game. Online people could be taken at face value…you could tell by the color of their name the level of “honor” they had achieved within the game. I enjoyed my time in the game immensely. Yet my brief encounters with people in Lineage left me struggling with profound principles!
I suddenly realized that with more time, some interactions could easily become bonding experiences. It’s no wonder that people are being sucked away from improving their real-world un-perfect relationships and into no-effort fantasyland relationships! What chance do our children have of surviving such options when the going gets tough in real life? What place does traditional family even hold in the next generation? What place does it still hold in this generation?
As a teacher and grandmother, I know that if you ask a child of any culture to list things that s/he is most thankful for, “family” is usually first. It is the same for most adults. Why is that? I argue that culture and family lie at the very heart of who we are. Consider the adoptive child who may expend great effort during a lifetime to locate “birth roots” as an aspect of who s/he really is. Perhaps a small gap exists for teens who are seeking independence from family, yet if given an entry path to ponder “how things are,” most teens admit gratitude for family.
How will family, culture, society, and social dynamics play out in cyberspace? Will the majority of people continue to wander unpurposefully in the virtual world without their real-world ‘significant others’ and at the mercy of some developer’s environment? Will mankind magically save himself from the character ruin that can’t help but result from persistent cyber deceit?
How can game developers tap into the power that motivates a person to seek his roots, his family, his identity, and his culture…and to reflect, ponder, publish, celebrate, and share his findings in a synergized or dramatic and exciting social setting?
I suddenly realized that with more time, some interactions could easily become bonding experiences. It’s no wonder that people are being sucked away from improving their real-world un-perfect relationships and into no-effort fantasyland relationships! What chance do our children have of surviving such options when the going gets tough in real life? What place does traditional family even hold in the next generation? What place does it still hold in this generation?
As a teacher and grandmother, I know that if you ask a child of any culture to list things that s/he is most thankful for, “family” is usually first. It is the same for most adults. Why is that? I argue that culture and family lie at the very heart of who we are. Consider the adoptive child who may expend great effort during a lifetime to locate “birth roots” as an aspect of who s/he really is. Perhaps a small gap exists for teens who are seeking independence from family, yet if given an entry path to ponder “how things are,” most teens admit gratitude for family.
How will family, culture, society, and social dynamics play out in cyberspace? Will the majority of people continue to wander unpurposefully in the virtual world without their real-world ‘significant others’ and at the mercy of some developer’s environment? Will mankind magically save himself from the character ruin that can’t help but result from persistent cyber deceit?
How can game developers tap into the power that motivates a person to seek his roots, his family, his identity, and his culture…and to reflect, ponder, publish, celebrate, and share his findings in a synergized or dramatic and exciting social setting?
Sunday, November 21, 2004
MMOG: Lineage
Character’s name- Tegra (short for TEacher-GRAmma)
Class- Knight, level 4, Hit Pt. 43
Weapons- daggers, wide sword, Apprentice sword, appr. Wizard boots and armor, 134 arrows plus 9 silver arrows and a short bow
Favorite creature- Deer
“Don’t bother Grandma. She is studying.” Three of our grandchildren ages 7, 11, and 14 could plainly see that I was fully immersed in something that I called ‘a massively multiplayer online game.’ They watched and cheered for Tegra, my online character, as she searched for food just beyond the goblins of Hidden Valley. Tegra chased and killed a deer, and then fled from several angry Orc Archers back to the village…where she slew the one that followed her through the gate while he was shooting arrows at her. Was this a good thing for my kids to see? I assured them it was an assignment, and I did not know if it was necessarily a good thing. But I couldn't deny that they thought it was good!
As for learning the game, experience was a better teacher than text descriptions. It took me several hours into the game to become brave enough to gain any rank. At last I discovered that dying was of little consequence, and that one could accumulate property and status more quickly by taking calculated risks.
Members of our cohort were scheduled to be online Thursday evening. A large number of the players passing randomly through Hidden Valley during the evening seemed vaguely familiar! I told one of them I was hungry. “Follow me,” he replied, and within a couple of minutes he led me to meat on the ground and I was filled. But I couldn’t keep up with him and I forgot his character’s name. I joined a couple of other parties but soon lost them.
Eight or ten people finally congregated in the village. One of the group asked, “7150?” It was us! Most of the group responded affirmatively. Some typed short versions of their names. It was a great moment! We decided to stick together, to teleport ourselves into the cave and try to take out the oppressors there. Before leaving the village we visited the Haste Master, then killed a few goblins on our way to the cave. What fun to belong to a group…to defend, help, and to cheer for each other! We were awesomely powerful against the cave monsters. I was sad to finally die in the cave, but the comrade who died at the same place typed “Don’t let that … get my corpse!” and “Go get ‘em guys!” It was a great way to wind up the evening.
Class- Knight, level 4, Hit Pt. 43
Weapons- daggers, wide sword, Apprentice sword, appr. Wizard boots and armor, 134 arrows plus 9 silver arrows and a short bow
Favorite creature- Deer
“Don’t bother Grandma. She is studying.” Three of our grandchildren ages 7, 11, and 14 could plainly see that I was fully immersed in something that I called ‘a massively multiplayer online game.’ They watched and cheered for Tegra, my online character, as she searched for food just beyond the goblins of Hidden Valley. Tegra chased and killed a deer, and then fled from several angry Orc Archers back to the village…where she slew the one that followed her through the gate while he was shooting arrows at her. Was this a good thing for my kids to see? I assured them it was an assignment, and I did not know if it was necessarily a good thing. But I couldn't deny that they thought it was good!
As for learning the game, experience was a better teacher than text descriptions. It took me several hours into the game to become brave enough to gain any rank. At last I discovered that dying was of little consequence, and that one could accumulate property and status more quickly by taking calculated risks.
Members of our cohort were scheduled to be online Thursday evening. A large number of the players passing randomly through Hidden Valley during the evening seemed vaguely familiar! I told one of them I was hungry. “Follow me,” he replied, and within a couple of minutes he led me to meat on the ground and I was filled. But I couldn’t keep up with him and I forgot his character’s name. I joined a couple of other parties but soon lost them.
Eight or ten people finally congregated in the village. One of the group asked, “7150?” It was us! Most of the group responded affirmatively. Some typed short versions of their names. It was a great moment! We decided to stick together, to teleport ourselves into the cave and try to take out the oppressors there. Before leaving the village we visited the Haste Master, then killed a few goblins on our way to the cave. What fun to belong to a group…to defend, help, and to cheer for each other! We were awesomely powerful against the cave monsters. I was sad to finally die in the cave, but the comrade who died at the same place typed “Don’t let that … get my corpse!” and “Go get ‘em guys!” It was a great way to wind up the evening.
Saturday, November 13, 2004
SYNTHESIS 2: TRUST
I firmly believe that trust is a condition that is earned, not an action that can be performed. Whenever I hear someone say, “Trust me,” I immediately suspect some element of trust to be missing. A person cannot simply decide to “trust” another with no foundation for trust.
Those who take risks to “trust” are not trusting. They are risking. Trust as a noun implies depth and assurance of feeling sometimes based on inconclusive evidence, but has foundations of cooperation and credible reputation.
Cooperation is the foundation on which good reputations are built. Boundaries between online and offline seem fuzzy to some, but most in my circles agree that cooperation, incentive, and reputation mean the same online as they do offline. Continued cooperation can ultimately and finally result in a feeling that a person or thing will not fail, or in other words, a beginning level of trust.
Deceit is the enemy of trust. In cyberspace, just as in the real world, a single deception can weaken or destroy a carefully established reputation, completely and permanently destroying any level of trust that might have been established.
Does anonymity jeopardize trust? Obviously so in many cases. But shouldn't others trust me if I sometimes prefer anonymity because I don’t want my e-mail account spammed? What level of accountability can be applied to anonymous participants? The sub-human behaviors I witnessed among anonymous participants who used nicknames on MUDs, MOOs, Newsgroups and IRC’s were a profound disappointment to me. But since I'm something of an idealist, I'm predicting a brighter future for Internet social software...which brings us to the topic of incentives.
There are two basic types of incentives; intrinsic and extrinsic. Intrinsic incentives are the natural consequences of one’s behavior, while extrinsic incentives are rewards or punishments imposed by regulatory law or other outside sources.
I think that only as consequences themselves become the incentives for behaviors will our hope for accountability and responsibility on the Internet continue to broaden. Deceit will become more exposed, users will become more cooperative, trustworthyness will grow and good reputations will develop. The phenomena will have gone full circle and will continue to spiral upward as the human family learns to manage their understandings and uses of technology. That is my idealistic view and my hope.
Those who take risks to “trust” are not trusting. They are risking. Trust as a noun implies depth and assurance of feeling sometimes based on inconclusive evidence, but has foundations of cooperation and credible reputation.
Cooperation is the foundation on which good reputations are built. Boundaries between online and offline seem fuzzy to some, but most in my circles agree that cooperation, incentive, and reputation mean the same online as they do offline. Continued cooperation can ultimately and finally result in a feeling that a person or thing will not fail, or in other words, a beginning level of trust.
Deceit is the enemy of trust. In cyberspace, just as in the real world, a single deception can weaken or destroy a carefully established reputation, completely and permanently destroying any level of trust that might have been established.
Does anonymity jeopardize trust? Obviously so in many cases. But shouldn't others trust me if I sometimes prefer anonymity because I don’t want my e-mail account spammed? What level of accountability can be applied to anonymous participants? The sub-human behaviors I witnessed among anonymous participants who used nicknames on MUDs, MOOs, Newsgroups and IRC’s were a profound disappointment to me. But since I'm something of an idealist, I'm predicting a brighter future for Internet social software...which brings us to the topic of incentives.
There are two basic types of incentives; intrinsic and extrinsic. Intrinsic incentives are the natural consequences of one’s behavior, while extrinsic incentives are rewards or punishments imposed by regulatory law or other outside sources.
I think that only as consequences themselves become the incentives for behaviors will our hope for accountability and responsibility on the Internet continue to broaden. Deceit will become more exposed, users will become more cooperative, trustworthyness will grow and good reputations will develop. The phenomena will have gone full circle and will continue to spiral upward as the human family learns to manage their understandings and uses of technology. That is my idealistic view and my hope.
Saturday, November 06, 2004
RELAY CHAT
Network: IRCnet
Channels: #Beginner, #Chatzone, #Family_Chat, #MusicOne
Interactions within “the safety of anonymity” on the IRC channels I visited were reminiscent of the day we set five baby cousins in a row for photographing; one cried, two climbed out of the row, one scowled at the crying person, and one just looked dazed. The babies were of different backgrounds with different agendas...together because of a common thread...they were cousins.
Hundreds of thousands of people log on to IRC every day from multiple backgrounds, joining chat rooms defined by some common thread. They sort themselves into categories, thus surrounding themselves with people who share a facet of their interests. Most of the actions I observed were RE-actions to each other’s mindless behavior.
Moral values and language(s) of each channel were somewhat indicated. Users of IRC have tools with which to set prefs and to pre-set certain responses. Entering and exiting channels in IRC are more defined than entering or exiting rooms in LambdaMOO.
LambdaMOO, on the other hand, has no "discussion" categories. Entering or exiting areas of the mansion are arbitrary. Hundreds of participants roam the corridors, yards, and rooms of the mansion interacting with whomever happens to be in each location. The ability of participants to alter the LambdaMOO environment provides an aspect of ownership not present in IRC.
Both environments allow participants to seek private exchanges with other named participants.
Albeit on a totally mindless level, the presence of people entering and leaving the chat rooms felt good. “#Beginner” was the most eventful of the four channels I visited. “Newness to chat rooms” was the supposed common thread for this group. You could get recognition from another person by typing in some personal greeting to them...and Wow! Back would come immediate substantiation; real “warm fuzzies!” At least you could pretend your validation was grounded on something real.
If your contributions were out of sync with channel norms you would soon be advised of it! Two participants were “kicked” from #Beginner by other participants for obnoxious behavior while I was online. In #Chatzone I noticed the Ban List contained a dozen or so names that all included sex-oriented terms. My mIRC Options would not allow me to visit the Pokemon site.
How can SO MANY people spend So-o-o much time engaged in mindless idle talk? What motivates them? What new elements might lend purpose or collaborative accomplishment to these social phenomena? Could relay-chat technology be applied toward service- or problem-solving environments? How would the social appeal of IRC be preserved or enhanced as part of a learning environment?
The five babies mentioned at the beginning of this blog have grown up, defined themselves, and bonded as cousins. Perhaps as the human family continues to mature and define itself, today’s idle interactions on IRC may develop into something more socially meaningful. But for now, maybe just having someone “standing by” serves a purpose of its own.
Channels: #Beginner, #Chatzone, #Family_Chat, #MusicOne
Interactions within “the safety of anonymity” on the IRC channels I visited were reminiscent of the day we set five baby cousins in a row for photographing; one cried, two climbed out of the row, one scowled at the crying person, and one just looked dazed. The babies were of different backgrounds with different agendas...together because of a common thread...they were cousins.
Hundreds of thousands of people log on to IRC every day from multiple backgrounds, joining chat rooms defined by some common thread. They sort themselves into categories, thus surrounding themselves with people who share a facet of their interests. Most of the actions I observed were RE-actions to each other’s mindless behavior.
Moral values and language(s) of each channel were somewhat indicated. Users of IRC have tools with which to set prefs and to pre-set certain responses. Entering and exiting channels in IRC are more defined than entering or exiting rooms in LambdaMOO.
LambdaMOO, on the other hand, has no "discussion" categories. Entering or exiting areas of the mansion are arbitrary. Hundreds of participants roam the corridors, yards, and rooms of the mansion interacting with whomever happens to be in each location. The ability of participants to alter the LambdaMOO environment provides an aspect of ownership not present in IRC.
Both environments allow participants to seek private exchanges with other named participants.
Albeit on a totally mindless level, the presence of people entering and leaving the chat rooms felt good. “#Beginner” was the most eventful of the four channels I visited. “Newness to chat rooms” was the supposed common thread for this group. You could get recognition from another person by typing in some personal greeting to them...and Wow! Back would come immediate substantiation; real “warm fuzzies!” At least you could pretend your validation was grounded on something real.
If your contributions were out of sync with channel norms you would soon be advised of it! Two participants were “kicked” from #Beginner by other participants for obnoxious behavior while I was online. In #Chatzone I noticed the Ban List contained a dozen or so names that all included sex-oriented terms. My mIRC Options would not allow me to visit the Pokemon site.
How can SO MANY people spend So-o-o much time engaged in mindless idle talk? What motivates them? What new elements might lend purpose or collaborative accomplishment to these social phenomena? Could relay-chat technology be applied toward service- or problem-solving environments? How would the social appeal of IRC be preserved or enhanced as part of a learning environment?
The five babies mentioned at the beginning of this blog have grown up, defined themselves, and bonded as cousins. Perhaps as the human family continues to mature and define itself, today’s idle interactions on IRC may develop into something more socially meaningful. But for now, maybe just having someone “standing by” serves a purpose of its own.
Sunday, October 31, 2004
MOO
Social interaction in a MOO involves the construction of objects. The emote modality makes possible a more structured and flexible communication environment than is found in other types of programs. These capabilities present an exciting potential for more committed relationships and more interactive creative depth than is possible in newsgroups, blogs, chat rooms or fanfiction. It also presents a greater potential for hurtful or unethical behavior.
Pavel Curtis, the creator of LambdaMOO, wrote “The Incredible Tale of LambdaMOO”
http://www.g4techtv.com/techtvvault/features/38666/. He noted that during the earliest days of LambdaMOO, through the beginning of 1991, everything was fascinating every day. Several months later two connections arrived from Penn State University who used persistent annoying language and he felt the need to moderate. He explained, “I wrote the first version of the LambdaMOO "@toad" command, for permanently destroying a user's character and all of its possessions. Some of the shine was off the apple, never to return.”
As an “All-powerful Wizard” Curtis and his group moderated the site until the task became unmanageable, at which time he posted an announcement that he termed “The abdication of the wizards from the "discipline/manners/arbitration business," stating that they would no longer be making what he termed "social decisions." The new direction of LambdaMOO was known as LTAND.
After LTAND, inter-player strife and harassment rose and LambdaMOO slowly became a rougher place. Pavel Curtis felt trapped in an unsustainable economic and political situation. Several efforts to move LambdaMOO to a working, stable form of self-government failed. Deep in its very structure, LambdaMOO was dependant on the wizards and on the owner of its machine. Social policy pervaded nearly every aspect of operations, and only the wizards could carry out those operations. As a result, the wizards were forced to make social decisions. Every time they made one, it seemed, someone took offense. How could peace and a tolerable workload be achieved?
What lies ahead for LambdaMOO? Looking at promising trends in Internet use, Curtis and many others envision the technology of LambdaMOO emerging in exciting new ways, but it won't be easy.
“What would "something better" look like?” asked Curtis. “On the top of my personal list is a vastly more equitable distribution of both power and economics. If these online "virtual" communities are to have the same robustness as the more physically oriented ones, they must become pliant and mutable under the same forces that cause RL communities to grow and change. It must be possible for incompatible sub-communities to separate and grow apart, thereby relieving the kinds of stresses that constantly tear at LambdaMOO. It must be possible for individuals to completely control their own creations, without the specter of an all-powerful wizard looming in the background, distorting all natural social interactions.
“When these things happen, when online communities can form and break apart as fluidly and naturally as do face-to-face ones, something dramatic will be taking place in the history of the human race. If you look closely at the Internet today, you can begin to see it happening already, in newsgroups and in the World Wide Web. It's still not here in the area of more synchronous interactions, but I know for a fact that it's coming; I'm working hard for it every day. We have only to hold on, to keep dreaming the dream; more than at any other time in human history, dreaming is nearly enough to make it happen.”
The fact that MOO programmers are researching and working toward more effective cyberspace learning sites where users develop committed and responsible relationships is intriguing and promising. Loyd Blankenship, an experienced programmer http://www.sla.purdue.edu/blackmon/moo/program.html, was intrigued when he first logged onto a MOO because of the infinite possibilities of a user-extendable, multi-user virtual reality. At the same time he was appalled because of the scarcity of documentation and help for new users.
Great minds are needed to balance the “government” of MOO communities, to engage “gaming principles” http://www.mud.co.uk/richard/hcds.htm, to document the programming language, and to create safe environments for learning.
Pavel Curtis, the creator of LambdaMOO, wrote “The Incredible Tale of LambdaMOO”
http://www.g4techtv.com/techtvvault/features/38666/. He noted that during the earliest days of LambdaMOO, through the beginning of 1991, everything was fascinating every day. Several months later two connections arrived from Penn State University who used persistent annoying language and he felt the need to moderate. He explained, “I wrote the first version of the LambdaMOO "@toad" command, for permanently destroying a user's character and all of its possessions. Some of the shine was off the apple, never to return.”
As an “All-powerful Wizard” Curtis and his group moderated the site until the task became unmanageable, at which time he posted an announcement that he termed “The abdication of the wizards from the "discipline/manners/arbitration business," stating that they would no longer be making what he termed "social decisions." The new direction of LambdaMOO was known as LTAND.
After LTAND, inter-player strife and harassment rose and LambdaMOO slowly became a rougher place. Pavel Curtis felt trapped in an unsustainable economic and political situation. Several efforts to move LambdaMOO to a working, stable form of self-government failed. Deep in its very structure, LambdaMOO was dependant on the wizards and on the owner of its machine. Social policy pervaded nearly every aspect of operations, and only the wizards could carry out those operations. As a result, the wizards were forced to make social decisions. Every time they made one, it seemed, someone took offense. How could peace and a tolerable workload be achieved?
What lies ahead for LambdaMOO? Looking at promising trends in Internet use, Curtis and many others envision the technology of LambdaMOO emerging in exciting new ways, but it won't be easy.
“What would "something better" look like?” asked Curtis. “On the top of my personal list is a vastly more equitable distribution of both power and economics. If these online "virtual" communities are to have the same robustness as the more physically oriented ones, they must become pliant and mutable under the same forces that cause RL communities to grow and change. It must be possible for incompatible sub-communities to separate and grow apart, thereby relieving the kinds of stresses that constantly tear at LambdaMOO. It must be possible for individuals to completely control their own creations, without the specter of an all-powerful wizard looming in the background, distorting all natural social interactions.
“When these things happen, when online communities can form and break apart as fluidly and naturally as do face-to-face ones, something dramatic will be taking place in the history of the human race. If you look closely at the Internet today, you can begin to see it happening already, in newsgroups and in the World Wide Web. It's still not here in the area of more synchronous interactions, but I know for a fact that it's coming; I'm working hard for it every day. We have only to hold on, to keep dreaming the dream; more than at any other time in human history, dreaming is nearly enough to make it happen.”
The fact that MOO programmers are researching and working toward more effective cyberspace learning sites where users develop committed and responsible relationships is intriguing and promising. Loyd Blankenship, an experienced programmer http://www.sla.purdue.edu/blackmon/moo/program.html, was intrigued when he first logged onto a MOO because of the infinite possibilities of a user-extendable, multi-user virtual reality. At the same time he was appalled because of the scarcity of documentation and help for new users.
Great minds are needed to balance the “government” of MOO communities, to engage “gaming principles” http://www.mud.co.uk/richard/hcds.htm, to document the programming language, and to create safe environments for learning.
MUDs and MOOs for education
You mean I have to explore these sinister underworld computer games for this university course? I try to avoid “D&D” dark-world stuff. As an elementary teacher I protect under-aged kids from exposure to it…to spark in them a work ethic, good friends, good times, good grades...after which there is no inclination for me to explore dark-world stuff for myself.
I’m feeling a little apprehensive. Zork was one of the first…The Great Underworld Empire. Reluctantly I download and install the application but it refuses to open. So, my computer has figured me out. After two attempts I settle for reading the online walkthrough version, which is somewhat engaging by itself…I want to see if I can get past the troll (I have to kill him or be killed) and go up the ladder in time to tie a rope to a beam and slide down it to the base of the dam, where there is a little pile of folded plastic; guess what it is? Right, it’s an inflatable boat! So, inflate it with the pump, then drop the pump, then get inside the boat, say “Launch,” and I’m floating off along the Frigid River… Great stuff. I think J. K. Rowling must have played Zork before she wrote the Harry Potter series.
Now for LambdaMOO, my last requirement. I enter as Infrared_Guest…thank goodness nobody knows me here. This place has architectural possibilities… hey somebody’s answering me! There are people here…do I dare look at them? Examine them? Is it polite to examine people? Here’s how you do it…@who. Now it wants me to “describe self, specify gender, proceed…” I feel myself getting committed. What makes this place tick? I want to find out. It has links to MOO Education information! Education!
One of the links http://web.nwe.ufl.edu/~ta ri/connections/index.html talks about alternative meeting space for classes and other academic or special-interest groups in MOO Connections. There are discussion groups gathered in forests, classes painting murals on caves, students constructing virtual museums, teachers meeting in barns and cafes, actors performing in virtual theaters, online conference sessions being held on beaches… anything a teacher and students might only dream about. But there are no traditional school buildings.
Some of the links from LambdaMOO ( http://www.lambdamoo.info/) describe high levels of user control, collaborative student activity, and interactive learning. Virtual communities are evolving to more effective cycles of productivity and credibility. We are not there yet, but the elements of balance without strife within communities are beginning to come into play.
According to Pavel Curtis, the founder of LambdaMOO, “It must be possible (in the future) for individuals to completely control their own creations, without the specter of an all-powerful wizard looming in the background, distorting all natural social interactions” (http://www.g4techtv.com/techtvvault/
features/38666/The_Incredible_Tale_of_LambdaMOO_pg1.html). What aspects of these cyberworlds could provide future opportunities for kids to practice management of their own work ethics? How long before the elements of ethical behavior and trust become a built-in incentive within given virtual communities? What parental controls will be needed? Has the inclination finally ignited for me to explore MUDs and MOOs as educational opportunities for the future? I’ve always wanted to learn how to play the piano… with good friends, good times, and good grades. Maybe collaboratively, in a cliff-walled canyon where the sounds echo!
I’m feeling a little apprehensive. Zork was one of the first…The Great Underworld Empire. Reluctantly I download and install the application but it refuses to open. So, my computer has figured me out. After two attempts I settle for reading the online walkthrough version, which is somewhat engaging by itself…I want to see if I can get past the troll (I have to kill him or be killed) and go up the ladder in time to tie a rope to a beam and slide down it to the base of the dam, where there is a little pile of folded plastic; guess what it is? Right, it’s an inflatable boat! So, inflate it with the pump, then drop the pump, then get inside the boat, say “Launch,” and I’m floating off along the Frigid River… Great stuff. I think J. K. Rowling must have played Zork before she wrote the Harry Potter series.
Now for LambdaMOO, my last requirement. I enter as Infrared_Guest…thank goodness nobody knows me here. This place has architectural possibilities… hey somebody’s answering me! There are people here…do I dare look at them? Examine them? Is it polite to examine people? Here’s how you do it…@who. Now it wants me to “describe self, specify gender, proceed…” I feel myself getting committed. What makes this place tick? I want to find out. It has links to MOO Education information! Education!
One of the links http://web.nwe.ufl.edu/~ta ri/connections/index.html talks about alternative meeting space for classes and other academic or special-interest groups in MOO Connections. There are discussion groups gathered in forests, classes painting murals on caves, students constructing virtual museums, teachers meeting in barns and cafes, actors performing in virtual theaters, online conference sessions being held on beaches… anything a teacher and students might only dream about. But there are no traditional school buildings.
Some of the links from LambdaMOO ( http://www.lambdamoo.info/) describe high levels of user control, collaborative student activity, and interactive learning. Virtual communities are evolving to more effective cycles of productivity and credibility. We are not there yet, but the elements of balance without strife within communities are beginning to come into play.
According to Pavel Curtis, the founder of LambdaMOO, “It must be possible (in the future) for individuals to completely control their own creations, without the specter of an all-powerful wizard looming in the background, distorting all natural social interactions” (http://www.g4techtv.com/techtvvault/
features/38666/The_Incredible_Tale_of_LambdaMOO_pg1.html). What aspects of these cyberworlds could provide future opportunities for kids to practice management of their own work ethics? How long before the elements of ethical behavior and trust become a built-in incentive within given virtual communities? What parental controls will be needed? Has the inclination finally ignited for me to explore MUDs and MOOs as educational opportunities for the future? I’ve always wanted to learn how to play the piano… with good friends, good times, and good grades. Maybe collaboratively, in a cliff-walled canyon where the sounds echo!
Saturday, October 23, 2004
SYNTHESIS 1:ONLINE RISK MANAGEMENT
e-Commerce risk management is much like using natural consequences as support for teaching children. Whenever a participant trader progresses up the spiral staircase of customer confidence, any type of deceit or negligence on his part can affect his rating and his reputation. Online risk management systems have become quite self-regulating through the dynamics of exchange and cooperation. Learning about these dynamics is causing traders to take responsibility for their own credibility.
Traditional ways of dealing with fraud include fines and prison sentences. Those controls are EXTRINSIC, expensive, and ineffective. External controls defeat the building of trust relationships.
Risk-management controls, on the other hand, are INTRINSICALLY motivated, highly effective, and are free! These natural controls pave the way for cooperation, for the building of good reputations, and for eventual trust relationships to develop.
The goal for online risk management is to document good and bad transactions, automatically establishing reputations of trustworthiness. I would say that incentive is the first principle of an online reputation reporting system, although incentives at the beginning may be in conflict with each other! Cooperation is required to develop the system. Cooperation is also required to gather feedback from those making transactions on the Internet. As cooperation increases, incentives become more synchronous with those of the trading community.
According to the Kollock article, the incentive to participate may first be provided by ease of use and trustworthiness of the software itself. Designers had to provide an entry path that would invite participants to respond. The more powerful incentives, however, come later. They are a result of participating in the system. Material benefits, social participation, and a prestigious reputation made possible through the rating systems then become the incentives. Natural consequences of cooperation and synchronized incentives at work are the satisfaction of reputations and trust relationships in direct proportion to participants' worthiness ratings.
It’s pretty amazing to learn how these systems can be designed to generate credible reports from the aggregated feedback of participants. In turn, stakeholders tend to reinforce the trust that is vested in them by improving their performance. What goes around comes around. Life is like that, and the civilized world is becoming ever more accountable. I like the way this thing is headed. We are the benefactors.
Traditional ways of dealing with fraud include fines and prison sentences. Those controls are EXTRINSIC, expensive, and ineffective. External controls defeat the building of trust relationships.
Risk-management controls, on the other hand, are INTRINSICALLY motivated, highly effective, and are free! These natural controls pave the way for cooperation, for the building of good reputations, and for eventual trust relationships to develop.
The goal for online risk management is to document good and bad transactions, automatically establishing reputations of trustworthiness. I would say that incentive is the first principle of an online reputation reporting system, although incentives at the beginning may be in conflict with each other! Cooperation is required to develop the system. Cooperation is also required to gather feedback from those making transactions on the Internet. As cooperation increases, incentives become more synchronous with those of the trading community.
According to the Kollock article, the incentive to participate may first be provided by ease of use and trustworthiness of the software itself. Designers had to provide an entry path that would invite participants to respond. The more powerful incentives, however, come later. They are a result of participating in the system. Material benefits, social participation, and a prestigious reputation made possible through the rating systems then become the incentives. Natural consequences of cooperation and synchronized incentives at work are the satisfaction of reputations and trust relationships in direct proportion to participants' worthiness ratings.
It’s pretty amazing to learn how these systems can be designed to generate credible reports from the aggregated feedback of participants. In turn, stakeholders tend to reinforce the trust that is vested in them by improving their performance. What goes around comes around. Life is like that, and the civilized world is becoming ever more accountable. I like the way this thing is headed. We are the benefactors.
Sunday, October 17, 2004
FAN FICTION
Three FanFiction authors whose writings I enjoyed:
Miss Piratess - http://www.fanfiction.net/s/1666372/1/
39 excellent chapters! 497 reviews!
mnwugn86 - http://www.fanfiction.net/s/2068461/1/
another Cinderella story, first installment
Rosa Cotton - http://www.fanfiction.net/s/1979932/1/
…this 17-year-old is gifted!
My story on FanFiction: http://www.fanfiction.net/s/2099338/1/
What makes FanFiction so popular? What motivates students to write more prolifically than they ever would in a classroom setting? Is it the freedom to fantasize? To share one’s life through fantasies? To receive feedback and to read what others fantasized? Does it serve as an escape from the real world? Does it provide links with the real world? What is the worth of accomplishment in a social setting and then being applauded and encouraged by others to continue?
Many online FanFiction authors are obviously striving for excellence, seemingly without the constant supervision of a teacher. Writing for excellence for FanFiction becomes an endeavor to maintain one’s social status as an insider in the writing/reviewing community.
Conversely, K-12 teachers often try to read and respond to everything that their students write. They spend long hours checking papers. However, if one teacher is able to read everything that his or her students write, then the students probably aren't writing enough. To bridge the gap, some teachers encourage parent partnerships, student-authored traveling books, student writing teams, or other programs to engage their students in a greater amount of writing. Is FanFiction an answer to the problem of motivating students to write beyond their teacher’s capacity to read? What motivation factors does introducing students to a FanFiction community enhance? What safeguards are necessary? What safeguards are available for young beginning authors in the elementary grades?
FanFiction does involve obvious concerns for miners in spite of the many user-friendly self-checking features. What can be done to protect students from encountering offensive content on these sites?
This sounds naive to even suggest it, but I wonder how a similar level of motivation might occur apart from the Internet, perhaps on a district-wide grade-level system for elementary writers? What elements for motivation would need to be in place? Could off-line software ever be as compelling as the online version? For kids of specific grade levels, could off-line software be implemented across a district system that includes all of the features of the online version? I was very amazed to find so many FanFiction communities of budding authors who were motivated to reach for excellence in their writing. I would now be amazed if all my questions hadn’t already been somewhat answered. The next problem is to find out what has already been done toward FanFiction-like digitized publishing for those beginning authors in the elementary grades.
Miss Piratess - http://www.fanfiction.net/s/1666372/1/
39 excellent chapters! 497 reviews!
mnwugn86 - http://www.fanfiction.net/s/2068461/1/
another Cinderella story, first installment
Rosa Cotton - http://www.fanfiction.net/s/1979932/1/
…this 17-year-old is gifted!
My story on FanFiction: http://www.fanfiction.net/s/2099338/1/
What makes FanFiction so popular? What motivates students to write more prolifically than they ever would in a classroom setting? Is it the freedom to fantasize? To share one’s life through fantasies? To receive feedback and to read what others fantasized? Does it serve as an escape from the real world? Does it provide links with the real world? What is the worth of accomplishment in a social setting and then being applauded and encouraged by others to continue?
Many online FanFiction authors are obviously striving for excellence, seemingly without the constant supervision of a teacher. Writing for excellence for FanFiction becomes an endeavor to maintain one’s social status as an insider in the writing/reviewing community.
Conversely, K-12 teachers often try to read and respond to everything that their students write. They spend long hours checking papers. However, if one teacher is able to read everything that his or her students write, then the students probably aren't writing enough. To bridge the gap, some teachers encourage parent partnerships, student-authored traveling books, student writing teams, or other programs to engage their students in a greater amount of writing. Is FanFiction an answer to the problem of motivating students to write beyond their teacher’s capacity to read? What motivation factors does introducing students to a FanFiction community enhance? What safeguards are necessary? What safeguards are available for young beginning authors in the elementary grades?
FanFiction does involve obvious concerns for miners in spite of the many user-friendly self-checking features. What can be done to protect students from encountering offensive content on these sites?
This sounds naive to even suggest it, but I wonder how a similar level of motivation might occur apart from the Internet, perhaps on a district-wide grade-level system for elementary writers? What elements for motivation would need to be in place? Could off-line software ever be as compelling as the online version? For kids of specific grade levels, could off-line software be implemented across a district system that includes all of the features of the online version? I was very amazed to find so many FanFiction communities of budding authors who were motivated to reach for excellence in their writing. I would now be amazed if all my questions hadn’t already been somewhat answered. The next problem is to find out what has already been done toward FanFiction-like digitized publishing for those beginning authors in the elementary grades.
Saturday, October 09, 2004
HOURS spent EDUBLOGGING
If one is to receive points, then one must report hours spent edublogging…
I Edublogged for eight hours so far :-).
I Edublogged for eight hours so far :-).
Thursday, October 07, 2004
EDUBLOGGING
Five great blogs I followed this week are:
ELearning Jump Page: http://www.internettime.com/enew.htm
The best of research, blogs, forums and just plain learning!
Elearning Post: http://www.elearningpost.com/
Link- Dan Saffer’s blogs
RoBlog dot org: http://loki.lokislabs.org/weblog/
Rob Adams’ blog on usability, software design and development
EduResources Weblog: http://radio.weblogs.com/0114870/
Higher Education Resources Online
Tomalak’s Realm: http://www.tomalak.org/
Daily Internet and Technology news
Two topics that interested me were (1) e-Learning strategies, and (2) re-usable learning objects. “Strategies” and “Objects” are two distinctly different topics in learning. STRATEGIES deals with the methodologies that we design to motivate specific learners. OBJECTS, I think, means instructional pieces of content that can be grabbed to learn or teach a concept. How might these two resources be considered in context with each other? How might a set of learning strategies compliment a catalog of re-usable objects? What is the best example so far of cataloged learning objects? What are the drawbacks of cataloging LOs? Does the relationship between strategies and objects represent social patterns over time?
While lurking with other users in edublog communities I stumbled across alternative aggregators that claimed to have power to organize and simplify my lurkings. Words kept popping up that demanded definition, such as Furl. Did “Furl” apply to the education scene that I’d been reading about? I was drawn to links such as http://www.furl.net/learnMore.jsp to find out what “Furl” means. Could I “Furl” the blog comments that I’d located on ‘Strategies’ and ‘Objects’ for easy reference? Hmm. My new SharpReader guided me back on track from Furling. Even “lurkers” apparently seek social interaction. They may eventually feel competent enough to become contributing members of the blogging community where they’ve been lurking. Does lurking represent a social pattern over time? Is learning happening here?
A much larger interactive social pattern becomes evident. Traditionally, corporate walls have kept smart employees IN and their customers OUT. Interactive social software is tearing down those corporate walls and causing the most exciting conversation business has ever engaged in. With a simple customer blog in place, a company can make announcements to its Web customers immediately. All customers can benefit from a question asked by only one. Through the intimacy found in blog culture conversation, customers can get to know workers—and vice-versa. “Affiliation breeds loyalty. Customers begin to talk among themselves. A typo that would be an embarrassment in an advertisement becomes a sign of authenticity.”
How can the emerging social patterns that are evident in e-Commerce be compared with emerging social patterns in e-Learning, both nationally and globally? How do these patterns impact education and learning? How do they impact cultural awareness? If affiliation breeds loyalty, if customers talk among themselves, is it even possible that dissenting factions could evolve toward global peace?
What is the emerging role of an instructional designer? How should “learning strategies” and “learning objects” be organized in light of these emerging social patterns? Hm.
ELearning Jump Page: http://www.internettime.com/enew.htm
The best of research, blogs, forums and just plain learning!
Elearning Post: http://www.elearningpost.com/
Link- Dan Saffer’s blogs
RoBlog dot org: http://loki.lokislabs.org/weblog/
Rob Adams’ blog on usability, software design and development
EduResources Weblog: http://radio.weblogs.com/0114870/
Higher Education Resources Online
Tomalak’s Realm: http://www.tomalak.org/
Daily Internet and Technology news
Two topics that interested me were (1) e-Learning strategies, and (2) re-usable learning objects. “Strategies” and “Objects” are two distinctly different topics in learning. STRATEGIES deals with the methodologies that we design to motivate specific learners. OBJECTS, I think, means instructional pieces of content that can be grabbed to learn or teach a concept. How might these two resources be considered in context with each other? How might a set of learning strategies compliment a catalog of re-usable objects? What is the best example so far of cataloged learning objects? What are the drawbacks of cataloging LOs? Does the relationship between strategies and objects represent social patterns over time?
While lurking with other users in edublog communities I stumbled across alternative aggregators that claimed to have power to organize and simplify my lurkings. Words kept popping up that demanded definition, such as Furl. Did “Furl” apply to the education scene that I’d been reading about? I was drawn to links such as http://www.furl.net/learnMore.jsp to find out what “Furl” means. Could I “Furl” the blog comments that I’d located on ‘Strategies’ and ‘Objects’ for easy reference? Hmm. My new SharpReader guided me back on track from Furling. Even “lurkers” apparently seek social interaction. They may eventually feel competent enough to become contributing members of the blogging community where they’ve been lurking. Does lurking represent a social pattern over time? Is learning happening here?
A much larger interactive social pattern becomes evident. Traditionally, corporate walls have kept smart employees IN and their customers OUT. Interactive social software is tearing down those corporate walls and causing the most exciting conversation business has ever engaged in. With a simple customer blog in place, a company can make announcements to its Web customers immediately. All customers can benefit from a question asked by only one. Through the intimacy found in blog culture conversation, customers can get to know workers—and vice-versa. “Affiliation breeds loyalty. Customers begin to talk among themselves. A typo that would be an embarrassment in an advertisement becomes a sign of authenticity.”
How can the emerging social patterns that are evident in e-Commerce be compared with emerging social patterns in e-Learning, both nationally and globally? How do these patterns impact education and learning? How do they impact cultural awareness? If affiliation breeds loyalty, if customers talk among themselves, is it even possible that dissenting factions could evolve toward global peace?
What is the emerging role of an instructional designer? How should “learning strategies” and “learning objects” be organized in light of these emerging social patterns? Hm.
Friday, October 01, 2004
BLOG HOPPING
Five great sites that I’ve been following this week:
MICHELLE MALKIN - http://michellemalkin.com/
Michelle is a newspaper journalist and Fox News contributor who publishes 4–6 new articles daily and maintains a good blogroll
JEN SPEAKS - http://www.freakinjen.us/weblog.php.
I don’t think this is Jen’s homepage so I’ll keep looking for it… Jen wrote, “Oh Blogroll. I love you so. You bring to me at the click of a mouse other smart, sassy intelligent people in the world who care about the same thing I do... “ This site not only carries Jen’s writings, but extensive blogrolls and other references.
CLICKNEWZ! BEHIND THE SCENES WITH LYNNE TERRY - http://clicknewz.blogspot.com/
Lynn Terry, a Tennessee mom, works from home full-time in Web Development and Internet Marketing.
FOX NEWS CHANNEL, GRETA VAN SUSTEREN - http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,133450,00.html.
Despite a busy news page with a lot of advertising, Greta’s navigational tools were quite fascinating! I especially liked her ARCHIVE window.
THE STORMIN MORMON - http://stormin-mormon.blogspot.com/
This was the result of a Google search for “children teaching and Mormon.” This site has been blogged only sporadically, like mine so far, but I do like the homepage and it does hold promise... like mine.
The Culture of Blogs:
Bloggers are people. Egocentric, fun-loving, unique people. They come in all styles, each with his or her unique voice and tone, falling haphazardly within the broader spectrum of blog cultures that can be somewhat differentiated by search terms. The interesting thing about blog cultures is that you can belong to more than one culture. You can belong to as many cultures as you decide to.
Numberless fascinating “cultures” seem to exist in the blogging world, but I’d like to reduce them to two basic realms that may reveal my personal bias: (1) The vast majority of blogs that I've seen seem to originate on a high intellectual level, are goal-oriented or purposive and reflect a high degree of respect for the human race by voice. (2) A smaller segment of bloggers seem to focus on pointless self-indulgence or smart remarks with no constructive goals, or they seem to take delight in profaning human dignity.
Signs of these two realms may become evident by the types and amount of jargon, slang and/or profanity that is used by bloggers and how that translates to the level of respect that the blogger may have for humanity. Within these two separate realms there exists numberless blogging cultures that I haven't met yet.
I tried using appropriate search terms to discover a really great blogger whose example I might want to follow… one who thinks like I do about topics I’m interested in but who knows more than I do. I think the bloggers listed here have demonstrated a high regard for people along with some of the qualities and features that I eventually want in my own blog. But none of these blogs exemplify all of them. Because of reading these blogs and following links from them, though, I’m smarter than I was. I am learning! And isn’t that what blogging is about?
Hours logged - one (1) hour total five days this week reading blogs.
MICHELLE MALKIN - http://michellemalkin.com/
Michelle is a newspaper journalist and Fox News contributor who publishes 4–6 new articles daily and maintains a good blogroll
JEN SPEAKS - http://www.freakinjen.us/weblog.php.
I don’t think this is Jen’s homepage so I’ll keep looking for it… Jen wrote, “Oh Blogroll. I love you so. You bring to me at the click of a mouse other smart, sassy intelligent people in the world who care about the same thing I do... “ This site not only carries Jen’s writings, but extensive blogrolls and other references.
CLICKNEWZ! BEHIND THE SCENES WITH LYNNE TERRY - http://clicknewz.blogspot.com/
Lynn Terry, a Tennessee mom, works from home full-time in Web Development and Internet Marketing.
FOX NEWS CHANNEL, GRETA VAN SUSTEREN - http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,133450,00.html.
Despite a busy news page with a lot of advertising, Greta’s navigational tools were quite fascinating! I especially liked her ARCHIVE window.
THE STORMIN MORMON - http://stormin-mormon.blogspot.com/
This was the result of a Google search for “children teaching and Mormon.” This site has been blogged only sporadically, like mine so far, but I do like the homepage and it does hold promise... like mine.
The Culture of Blogs:
Bloggers are people. Egocentric, fun-loving, unique people. They come in all styles, each with his or her unique voice and tone, falling haphazardly within the broader spectrum of blog cultures that can be somewhat differentiated by search terms. The interesting thing about blog cultures is that you can belong to more than one culture. You can belong to as many cultures as you decide to.
Numberless fascinating “cultures” seem to exist in the blogging world, but I’d like to reduce them to two basic realms that may reveal my personal bias: (1) The vast majority of blogs that I've seen seem to originate on a high intellectual level, are goal-oriented or purposive and reflect a high degree of respect for the human race by voice. (2) A smaller segment of bloggers seem to focus on pointless self-indulgence or smart remarks with no constructive goals, or they seem to take delight in profaning human dignity.
Signs of these two realms may become evident by the types and amount of jargon, slang and/or profanity that is used by bloggers and how that translates to the level of respect that the blogger may have for humanity. Within these two separate realms there exists numberless blogging cultures that I haven't met yet.
I tried using appropriate search terms to discover a really great blogger whose example I might want to follow… one who thinks like I do about topics I’m interested in but who knows more than I do. I think the bloggers listed here have demonstrated a high regard for people along with some of the qualities and features that I eventually want in my own blog. But none of these blogs exemplify all of them. Because of reading these blogs and following links from them, though, I’m smarter than I was. I am learning! And isn’t that what blogging is about?
Hours logged - one (1) hour total five days this week reading blogs.
Monday, September 27, 2004
THREAD MINI-ANALYSIS
John Brock certainly knew how to energize and maximize an effective community of interest when he posed his newsgroup question under the topic “Zero viruses” ad campaign?” comp.sys.mac.system.
Brock’s thread points out that although there are no Mac viruses, Mac chooses not to run an advertising campaign contrasting the huge number of Windows viruses with the total absence of Mac viruses. He then asks why Apple doesn’t run such an advertising campaign and mentions several possible reasons. He asks, “Would such a campaign provoke virus-writing communities to attack Mac’s OS X,” which is based on Unix and is much more secure than Windows? Having laid this possibility open for discussion, John Brock’s bottom-line question was, “Can you think of any other reasons why such an ad campaign might be a bad idea?”
A responder suggested that Apple’s advertising notoriously plays on style, not on technical terms. He was challenged by another responder with Websites to back up his counter-claims. Side-notes about Apple’s high prices and comparatively low sales crept into the discussion along with several carefully calculated “if-then” scenarios.
First, I think Brock was successful in capturing the attention of potential hackers/users by offering the prospect of gaining “an ego-satisfying piece of the action” (Raymond, p. 8). Mac users are a unique community. They belong to the “Mac Culture” and share common problems of “Mac-ness in a Windows world.” Mac users also share not having their personal information stolen or destroyed by viruses.
I noticed that gaming elements were evident in this thread as well. Much like ‘rescuing the princess without freeing the wicked dragon,’ Mac users were being asked to chip away at Mac’s incompatibility with Windows without compromising Mac’s security level. If they were in tune with Mac’s unique “human interface” culture they might even qualify to play on the advanced level. So is this newsgroup merely playing an exciting game? Or is it volleying with real-world stuff that lies at the core of global economy? Did Apple have anything to do with designing the opening question? How much, if any, is the company involved with this voluntary interaction? Will they take into account the information generated by this online community?
Respondents to this thread pooled their perspectives and I noticed that they would eventually feed off each other and the problem, seeming at times to emerge with a “coming together” of previously disjointed ideas. Raymond refers to this phenomenon as the “principle of understanding.” Even though some of Brock’s respondents made pointless snap-answers, others added valuable insight to the situation and a few of them took time to expand the knowledge base… such as George Berger, who noticed that Apple is the only corporation that makes its own hardware AND provides the OS and some applications software for their computers. I suspected Berger to be an inside man, not a hacker. But who knows? Personally, I’m 90% a Windows user because I use Windows at work. But for the 10% of the time that I use my Mac I continue to identify strongly with the Mac culture. Yes, I’m a Mac addict. For me it’s an EGO thing.
Brock’s thread points out that although there are no Mac viruses, Mac chooses not to run an advertising campaign contrasting the huge number of Windows viruses with the total absence of Mac viruses. He then asks why Apple doesn’t run such an advertising campaign and mentions several possible reasons. He asks, “Would such a campaign provoke virus-writing communities to attack Mac’s OS X,” which is based on Unix and is much more secure than Windows? Having laid this possibility open for discussion, John Brock’s bottom-line question was, “Can you think of any other reasons why such an ad campaign might be a bad idea?”
A responder suggested that Apple’s advertising notoriously plays on style, not on technical terms. He was challenged by another responder with Websites to back up his counter-claims. Side-notes about Apple’s high prices and comparatively low sales crept into the discussion along with several carefully calculated “if-then” scenarios.
First, I think Brock was successful in capturing the attention of potential hackers/users by offering the prospect of gaining “an ego-satisfying piece of the action” (Raymond, p. 8). Mac users are a unique community. They belong to the “Mac Culture” and share common problems of “Mac-ness in a Windows world.” Mac users also share not having their personal information stolen or destroyed by viruses.
I noticed that gaming elements were evident in this thread as well. Much like ‘rescuing the princess without freeing the wicked dragon,’ Mac users were being asked to chip away at Mac’s incompatibility with Windows without compromising Mac’s security level. If they were in tune with Mac’s unique “human interface” culture they might even qualify to play on the advanced level. So is this newsgroup merely playing an exciting game? Or is it volleying with real-world stuff that lies at the core of global economy? Did Apple have anything to do with designing the opening question? How much, if any, is the company involved with this voluntary interaction? Will they take into account the information generated by this online community?
Respondents to this thread pooled their perspectives and I noticed that they would eventually feed off each other and the problem, seeming at times to emerge with a “coming together” of previously disjointed ideas. Raymond refers to this phenomenon as the “principle of understanding.” Even though some of Brock’s respondents made pointless snap-answers, others added valuable insight to the situation and a few of them took time to expand the knowledge base… such as George Berger, who noticed that Apple is the only corporation that makes its own hardware AND provides the OS and some applications software for their computers. I suspected Berger to be an inside man, not a hacker. But who knows? Personally, I’m 90% a Windows user because I use Windows at work. But for the 10% of the time that I use my Mac I continue to identify strongly with the Mac culture. Yes, I’m a Mac addict. For me it’s an EGO thing.
Sunday, September 19, 2004
NEWSGROUP NEWBIE
Gaining an accurate overall impression of the Google Groups was like trying to eat an elephant. I must have started on the toenails, which didn’t taste good. Many of the comments I read were “idle talk” (sensationalistic or sensualistic). Others argued and resorted to finger pointing, which I noticed was against the Google Group policy. After at least five hours of surfing (not two) I finally located a moderately engaging group and spent a few more hours studying and comparing group participation with other sites before posting a comment of my own. Posting a comment necessitates returning to the site to see if others responded to yours! Woe is me, I’ve done it now.
Moderated groups seemed to attract more professional and focused comments than unmoderated groups. The soc.culture.Indian.telugu http://groups.google.com/groups?q=Indian+Telugu&hl=en contained a motion to begin moderating the group because of being plagued with numerous irrelevant cross-posts. Comments and votes to moderate were requested. The motion to moderate passed, 276: 64. One example of irrelevant multiple cross-posting is found on this site under topic heading “Trance-Formation of America: Epilogue.
The URL that I participated in was soc.religion.mormon, (a moderated discussion) > http://groups.google.com/groups?hl=en&lr=&ie=UTF-8&frame=right&th=3e7147eb7a86320d&seekm=10kdul3dlhg76ea%40news.supernews.com#link1 . The really great thing about this group was in the way that questions came from every perspective in a questioning way as Dr. Wiley is suggesting, with quotes and references, leaving the reader to arrive at his or her own conclusions and free to post his or her own viewpoint (subject to moderation for obvious reasons). Group member David Bowie presented impressive comments with this group. He knew how to write "I don't know," and "most Mormons seem to favor such-and-such," etc. It was a refreshing exchange of non-Mormon and Mormon logic without being hit over the head with the doctrine itself. His comment stated that the implication is made that all tribes of Israel have been identified in patriarchal blessings http://library.lds.org/nxt/gateway.dll/Magazines/Ensign/1995.htm/ensign%20november%201995.htm/priesthood%20blessings.htm. Clicking on Bowie’s link http://pmpkn.net/lx shows him to be Assistant Professor of Linguistics & English Language at the University of Central Florida. There were links to several of his published & unpublished papers on linguistics, including a 200-plus-page dissertation that I downloaded. Bowie’s favorite laws were: Jeanne's Two Laws of Chocolate:
If there is no chocolate in the
house, there is too little; some must be purchased. If there is
chocolate in the house, there is too much; it must be consumed.
A motto of a member of this group: "A soft answer turneth away wrath: but grievous words stir up anger." --Prov. 15:1. This member could be traced to the University of Wisconsin– LaCrosse: http://66.102.7.104/search?q=cache:aOLlc7alCMsJ:www.uwlax.edu/+&hl=en
In the discussion on polygamy Do the LDS know/acknowledge polygamy? I also responded to the question “But if God tells you not to go to jail over polygamy, should you still go to jail over polygamy?”
Total newsnet time = (how embarrasing) 13 hours
Questions have surfaced during these hours of surfing; Can specific search terms be used to obtain more credible findings? How credible can newsgroup comments be? What are the indicators of newsgroup credibility? How credible can I make my blogs?
Moderated groups seemed to attract more professional and focused comments than unmoderated groups. The soc.culture.Indian.telugu http://groups.google.com/groups?q=Indian+Telugu&hl=en contained a motion to begin moderating the group because of being plagued with numerous irrelevant cross-posts. Comments and votes to moderate were requested. The motion to moderate passed, 276: 64. One example of irrelevant multiple cross-posting is found on this site under topic heading “Trance-Formation of America: Epilogue.
The URL that I participated in was soc.religion.mormon, (a moderated discussion) > http://groups.google.com/groups?hl=en&lr=&ie=UTF-8&frame=right&th=3e7147eb7a86320d&seekm=10kdul3dlhg76ea%40news.supernews.com#link1 . The really great thing about this group was in the way that questions came from every perspective in a questioning way as Dr. Wiley is suggesting, with quotes and references, leaving the reader to arrive at his or her own conclusions and free to post his or her own viewpoint (subject to moderation for obvious reasons). Group member David Bowie presented impressive comments with this group. He knew how to write "I don't know," and "most Mormons seem to favor such-and-such," etc. It was a refreshing exchange of non-Mormon and Mormon logic without being hit over the head with the doctrine itself. His comment stated that the implication is made that all tribes of Israel have been identified in patriarchal blessings http://library.lds.org/nxt/gateway.dll/Magazines/Ensign/1995.htm/ensign%20november%201995.htm/priesthood%20blessings.htm. Clicking on Bowie’s link http://pmpkn.net/lx shows him to be Assistant Professor of Linguistics & English Language at the University of Central Florida. There were links to several of his published & unpublished papers on linguistics, including a 200-plus-page dissertation that I downloaded. Bowie’s favorite laws were: Jeanne's Two Laws of Chocolate:
If there is no chocolate in the
house, there is too little; some must be purchased. If there is
chocolate in the house, there is too much; it must be consumed.
A motto of a member of this group: "A soft answer turneth away wrath: but grievous words stir up anger." --Prov. 15:1. This member could be traced to the University of Wisconsin– LaCrosse: http://66.102.7.104/search?q=cache:aOLlc7alCMsJ:www.uwlax.edu/+&hl=en
In the discussion on polygamy Do the LDS know/acknowledge polygamy? I also responded to the question “But if God tells you not to go to jail over polygamy, should you still go to jail over polygamy?”
Total newsnet time = (how embarrasing) 13 hours
Questions have surfaced during these hours of surfing; Can specific search terms be used to obtain more credible findings? How credible can newsgroup comments be? What are the indicators of newsgroup credibility? How credible can I make my blogs?
Monday, September 13, 2004
Monday, September 06, 2004
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)


