The superior army had in its possession a good arsenal of existing weapons that had been refined over several generations. Norden, the new Chief of the Research Staff and an aggressive theoretical scientist, accused the existing staff of devoting itself to “perfecting old weapons instead of developing new ones.” Norden replaced some of the older scientists with young men. New technology was introduced immediately, based on Norden’s theoretical promises.
Clark’s story encompassed several issues. Most glaring was the fact that Norden wanted to replace the army’s “imperfect old weapons” with his dream machines, and then succeeded in convincing others to pursue his plans. However, Norden and his staff failed to accurately consider constraints of time and resources, standardization of new technology with existing technology, usability, and reliability.
Time and resource constraints were not planned for, nor were the limitations of new technologies. Instead, these issues were often encountered during critical maneuvers and with heavy penalties. For example, it was discovered after-the-fact that Norden's Sphere of Annihilation disintegrated itself along with its target.
Standardization was overlooked when a new class of torpedo had to be designed to carry the new “Sphere of Annihilation” that theoretically should have been carried on existing torpedoes.
Usability was not considered when the “Battle Analyser” replaced members of the Operations Staff, later requiring a team of five hundred technicians to maintain each Analyser... and a separate liner to follow along after each battleship to house technicians while they were off-duty.
Unreliability of the “Exponential Field” also became apparent during the heat of battle, causing demoralization of the army and giving ultimate advantage to the enemy.
The human element was also overlooked, as evidenced by replacing experienced staff members with inexperienced ones, and by the confusion, nervous breakdowns and chaos that resulted from trying to force men into the role of trained technicians to maintain and operate the Battle Analyser.
What is Clarke saying in his science fiction “Superior”? His perceptive story leads us through a few possible consequences of jumping directly from theory into the implementation of new technologies. One must wonder how Arthur Clarke could imagine with such accuracy!
* * *
“SUPERIORITY” was first published in The Magazine of Science Fiction and Fantasy, Aug., 1951, Collected in Expedition to Earth
