John Brock certainly knew how to energize and maximize an effective community of interest when he posed his newsgroup question under the topic “Zero viruses” ad campaign?” comp.sys.mac.system.
Brock’s thread points out that although there are no Mac viruses, Mac chooses not to run an advertising campaign contrasting the huge number of Windows viruses with the total absence of Mac viruses. He then asks why Apple doesn’t run such an advertising campaign and mentions several possible reasons. He asks, “Would such a campaign provoke virus-writing communities to attack Mac’s OS X,” which is based on Unix and is much more secure than Windows? Having laid this possibility open for discussion, John Brock’s bottom-line question was, “Can you think of any other reasons why such an ad campaign might be a bad idea?”
A responder suggested that Apple’s advertising notoriously plays on style, not on technical terms. He was challenged by another responder with Websites to back up his counter-claims. Side-notes about Apple’s high prices and comparatively low sales crept into the discussion along with several carefully calculated “if-then” scenarios.
First, I think Brock was successful in capturing the attention of potential hackers/users by offering the prospect of gaining “an ego-satisfying piece of the action” (Raymond, p. 8). Mac users are a unique community. They belong to the “Mac Culture” and share common problems of “Mac-ness in a Windows world.” Mac users also share not having their personal information stolen or destroyed by viruses.
I noticed that gaming elements were evident in this thread as well. Much like ‘rescuing the princess without freeing the wicked dragon,’ Mac users were being asked to chip away at Mac’s incompatibility with Windows without compromising Mac’s security level. If they were in tune with Mac’s unique “human interface” culture they might even qualify to play on the advanced level. So is this newsgroup merely playing an exciting game? Or is it volleying with real-world stuff that lies at the core of global economy? Did Apple have anything to do with designing the opening question? How much, if any, is the company involved with this voluntary interaction? Will they take into account the information generated by this online community?
Respondents to this thread pooled their perspectives and I noticed that they would eventually feed off each other and the problem, seeming at times to emerge with a “coming together” of previously disjointed ideas. Raymond refers to this phenomenon as the “principle of understanding.” Even though some of Brock’s respondents made pointless snap-answers, others added valuable insight to the situation and a few of them took time to expand the knowledge base… such as George Berger, who noticed that Apple is the only corporation that makes its own hardware AND provides the OS and some applications software for their computers. I suspected Berger to be an inside man, not a hacker. But who knows? Personally, I’m 90% a Windows user because I use Windows at work. But for the 10% of the time that I use my Mac I continue to identify strongly with the Mac culture. Yes, I’m a Mac addict. For me it’s an EGO thing.
Monday, September 27, 2004
Sunday, September 19, 2004
NEWSGROUP NEWBIE
Gaining an accurate overall impression of the Google Groups was like trying to eat an elephant. I must have started on the toenails, which didn’t taste good. Many of the comments I read were “idle talk” (sensationalistic or sensualistic). Others argued and resorted to finger pointing, which I noticed was against the Google Group policy. After at least five hours of surfing (not two) I finally located a moderately engaging group and spent a few more hours studying and comparing group participation with other sites before posting a comment of my own. Posting a comment necessitates returning to the site to see if others responded to yours! Woe is me, I’ve done it now.
Moderated groups seemed to attract more professional and focused comments than unmoderated groups. The soc.culture.Indian.telugu http://groups.google.com/groups?q=Indian+Telugu&hl=en contained a motion to begin moderating the group because of being plagued with numerous irrelevant cross-posts. Comments and votes to moderate were requested. The motion to moderate passed, 276: 64. One example of irrelevant multiple cross-posting is found on this site under topic heading “Trance-Formation of America: Epilogue.
The URL that I participated in was soc.religion.mormon, (a moderated discussion) > http://groups.google.com/groups?hl=en&lr=&ie=UTF-8&frame=right&th=3e7147eb7a86320d&seekm=10kdul3dlhg76ea%40news.supernews.com#link1 . The really great thing about this group was in the way that questions came from every perspective in a questioning way as Dr. Wiley is suggesting, with quotes and references, leaving the reader to arrive at his or her own conclusions and free to post his or her own viewpoint (subject to moderation for obvious reasons). Group member David Bowie presented impressive comments with this group. He knew how to write "I don't know," and "most Mormons seem to favor such-and-such," etc. It was a refreshing exchange of non-Mormon and Mormon logic without being hit over the head with the doctrine itself. His comment stated that the implication is made that all tribes of Israel have been identified in patriarchal blessings http://library.lds.org/nxt/gateway.dll/Magazines/Ensign/1995.htm/ensign%20november%201995.htm/priesthood%20blessings.htm. Clicking on Bowie’s link http://pmpkn.net/lx shows him to be Assistant Professor of Linguistics & English Language at the University of Central Florida. There were links to several of his published & unpublished papers on linguistics, including a 200-plus-page dissertation that I downloaded. Bowie’s favorite laws were: Jeanne's Two Laws of Chocolate:
If there is no chocolate in the
house, there is too little; some must be purchased. If there is
chocolate in the house, there is too much; it must be consumed.
A motto of a member of this group: "A soft answer turneth away wrath: but grievous words stir up anger." --Prov. 15:1. This member could be traced to the University of Wisconsin– LaCrosse: http://66.102.7.104/search?q=cache:aOLlc7alCMsJ:www.uwlax.edu/+&hl=en
In the discussion on polygamy Do the LDS know/acknowledge polygamy? I also responded to the question “But if God tells you not to go to jail over polygamy, should you still go to jail over polygamy?”
Total newsnet time = (how embarrasing) 13 hours
Questions have surfaced during these hours of surfing; Can specific search terms be used to obtain more credible findings? How credible can newsgroup comments be? What are the indicators of newsgroup credibility? How credible can I make my blogs?
Moderated groups seemed to attract more professional and focused comments than unmoderated groups. The soc.culture.Indian.telugu http://groups.google.com/groups?q=Indian+Telugu&hl=en contained a motion to begin moderating the group because of being plagued with numerous irrelevant cross-posts. Comments and votes to moderate were requested. The motion to moderate passed, 276: 64. One example of irrelevant multiple cross-posting is found on this site under topic heading “Trance-Formation of America: Epilogue.
The URL that I participated in was soc.religion.mormon, (a moderated discussion) > http://groups.google.com/groups?hl=en&lr=&ie=UTF-8&frame=right&th=3e7147eb7a86320d&seekm=10kdul3dlhg76ea%40news.supernews.com#link1 . The really great thing about this group was in the way that questions came from every perspective in a questioning way as Dr. Wiley is suggesting, with quotes and references, leaving the reader to arrive at his or her own conclusions and free to post his or her own viewpoint (subject to moderation for obvious reasons). Group member David Bowie presented impressive comments with this group. He knew how to write "I don't know," and "most Mormons seem to favor such-and-such," etc. It was a refreshing exchange of non-Mormon and Mormon logic without being hit over the head with the doctrine itself. His comment stated that the implication is made that all tribes of Israel have been identified in patriarchal blessings http://library.lds.org/nxt/gateway.dll/Magazines/Ensign/1995.htm/ensign%20november%201995.htm/priesthood%20blessings.htm. Clicking on Bowie’s link http://pmpkn.net/lx shows him to be Assistant Professor of Linguistics & English Language at the University of Central Florida. There were links to several of his published & unpublished papers on linguistics, including a 200-plus-page dissertation that I downloaded. Bowie’s favorite laws were: Jeanne's Two Laws of Chocolate:
If there is no chocolate in the
house, there is too little; some must be purchased. If there is
chocolate in the house, there is too much; it must be consumed.
A motto of a member of this group: "A soft answer turneth away wrath: but grievous words stir up anger." --Prov. 15:1. This member could be traced to the University of Wisconsin– LaCrosse: http://66.102.7.104/search?q=cache:aOLlc7alCMsJ:www.uwlax.edu/+&hl=en
In the discussion on polygamy Do the LDS know/acknowledge polygamy? I also responded to the question “But if God tells you not to go to jail over polygamy, should you still go to jail over polygamy?”
Total newsnet time = (how embarrasing) 13 hours
Questions have surfaced during these hours of surfing; Can specific search terms be used to obtain more credible findings? How credible can newsgroup comments be? What are the indicators of newsgroup credibility? How credible can I make my blogs?
Monday, September 13, 2004
Monday, September 06, 2004
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
