Sunday, January 27, 2008

COMPS #1

THE QUESTION:
How do you believe people learn? Ground your arguments in the literature. Given this set of beliefs, how would you utilize advanced technology to foster learning? Be specific using a target group of learners and a curriculum topic of your choice. Limit your answers to no more than 6 double-spaced pages.

MY BELIEFS ABOUT HOW PEOPLE LEARN
One’s early family social interactions form the foundations for future learning. By the time a teacher meets a new class of students they are already strongly set on individual learning trajectories. We see disadvantaged children that tend to fall further behind over time, while the children of highly literate parents seem to achieve academically with apparent ease (Hart and Risley, 1995).

School literacy begins at home. In a study of the literacy levels of early learners, Hart and Risley report, “When we looked at what was happening between the parents and children during the months the children were learning to talk, we saw the intergenerational transmission of the particular social dance practiced in the family” (1995). Hart and Risley add that children get better at what they practice, and having more language tools, more problem-solving approaches, more nuances, more fluency, more steps in the social dances of life is likely to contribute to their future academic success. Hart and Risley also emphasize the importance of a high proportion of “positive encouragements,” as opposed to negative imperatives to warn, prohibit, or criticize. Further, a recent study published in the Journal of Pediatrics indicates that even the time babies spend watching television—including “educational” television—may harm, rather than help language development because it replaces time that might otherwise be spent interacting, unless the television is being watched with a parent and it fosters increased parent-child interaction (Zimmerman, Christakis, and Meltzoff, 2007).

The effects of intergenerational transmission on learning. A crucial feature of effective teaching is that it elicits from students their pre-existing understanding of the concept to be taught and provides opportunities to build on—or challenge—the learner’s initial understanding” (Bransford, Brown, and Cocking, 2000, p 15). Consider for a moment that long ago, for better or for worse, my mother and father mentored values and traditions that my siblings and I each exemplify while raising our own children, and that our children tend to model while raising theirs. Even as a public school teacher, my style reflects the subtle innuendos from decades earlier that my mother possessed. Then, how much impact can formal education have on the learning trajectory of one who has already been so dramatically influenced? How can school interventions alter a low-aimed trajectory? The answer is repeated from many perspectives in the report of The National Academies by Bransford and his group (2000). Students come into the classroom with preconceptions about how the world works. If their initial understanding is not engaged by the instructor, they may fail to grasp the new concepts and information that are taught. When the learner’s prior experience has been engaged in the learning environment, conceptual change is enabled through skillful instruction and ongoing formative assessments to make the learner’s thinking visable. Conversely, many researchers claim that although school interventions improve standardized test scores, if crucial connections with the learner’s prior experience are missing, those hard-fought skills tend to fade and wash out in time (Hart and Risley, 1995).

Spheres of influence. Joyce Epstein recognized three “spheres of influence” that shape childrens’ lives: (1) family, (2) school, and (3) community (1995). She recommends increasing the overlap among the spheres of influence so that each sphere supports the other two, thus generating a more enduring improvement in the child’s learning trajectory as a result of school interventions. If schools promote activities to improve home-school partnering, the child’s prior experience at home is more likely to become engaged at school, and new knowledge is more likely to transfer to applications beyond the classroom.

Conceptual change. Although Piaget and other theorists assumed that disequilibrium drives conceptual change, Rochelle (1992) recognized that convergent ideas can also drive conceptual change. Both types of conceptual change occur within knowledge-, learner-, and assessment-centered classroom learning communities organized around the principles that support learning. Scientific conceptualization of new knowledge can be mentored by a perceptive instructor in problem- and inquiry-based environments (Bransford, et. al, 2000; Lave and Wenger, 1991). A metacognitive approach to instruction can help students refine concepts and gain higher levels of expertise organized around the principles that support understanding.

Social-cognitive learning. The social nature of learning and the power of mentoring were first taught by Lev Vygotsky (1978) and Albert Bandura (1986). The flood of research that followed substantiates the value of social-cognitive learning in classrooms, which is a logical follow-up to the dramatic impact of early family social interactions during the periods of early rapid brain growth (Shore, 1997). Although research emphasizes that the spheres of influence that shape childrens’ lives should work more closely together to promote a caring learning environment for students, home-school partnering remains low on most teachers’ priority lists. These and other research findings are not yet adequately understood or applied by teachers in practice.

UTILIZING ADVANCED TECHNOLOGIES
TO FOSTER HOME-SCHOOL LITERACY
My “dream-design” for instruction will target parents as learners for two reasons: (1) they are their child’s most influential teachers, and (2) parents need guidance to help their children, particularly within a peer learning community where their presence would be mostly asynchronous. The curriculum topic is “family literacy.” A dynamic site for a Student/Parent/Peer online authoring community will be established. The site will enable teachers to facilitate mechanisms patterned after existing programs of traveling books or literacy bags that some teachers currently facilitate in grades K-3.

The Internet is well-suited for keeping people connected. It abounds with developing websites for early literacy-learning. Current technology supports Massively Multi-player Online Games (MMOGs) and Massively Multi-learner Online Learning Environments (MMOLEs). Mentoring pedagogical agents and avatars can lead learners into entry paths to meet their peers, parents, or teachers online. But sadly missing from existing sites are mechanisms to increase the overlap of children’s spheres of influence.

Criteria for the site. Tools are lacking that could specifically increase interactivity between family, school, and community, particularly for the benefit of parents and their young pre-keyboarding authors. Much work is needed to design and create tools that:

--guide parents to position themselves in their child’s peer authoring community in ways to scaffold their child’s family-based stories for peer audiences so that young authors can understand more and be able to use what they have learned in new situations with their peers (Keyser, 2006; Bransford, et. al, 2000)

--empower teachers to easily facilitate literacy mechanisms with contextualized formative and summative assessments and two-way feedback capabilities

--provide objects for pre-keyboarding students on beginning reading levels to communicate using minimal texting while experiencing maximum literacy

--provide dynamic, highly motivating, educationally viable literacy frameworks and content for students and their peers to use collaboratively or individually

These are important convergent issues for future collaborative research by subject matter experts (SMEs) in the domains of family literacy, reading instruction, home-school partnering, instructional technology, cognitive science, and gaming.

Assessment of the home-school interactive literacy MMOLE will be based on (1) the degree to which it promotes overlap among childrens’ spheres of influence (Epstein, 1995), (2) the degree to which it employs the principles of how people learn in context with literacy learning (Bransford, et al, 2000), and (3) usability, social interaction, and self-reporting features. Busy parents will have the option to connect asynchronously yet effectively with their child’s learning community.

Adult learners. According to Bransford, et. al (2000), principles that empower adult learners are the same as the principles that allow people of all ages to achieve academically. Instructional design to help parents increase literacy practices at home needs to be learner-centered, knowledge-centered, assessment-centered, and with support provided for follow-up as parents incorporate new ideas into their family routines.
Four categories encompass the principles that the instruction needs to support. First, learners (parents) must be able to engage and integrate their preconceptions into conceptual beliefs more like those of scientists. Learners need to develop competency by organizing their own factual and conceptual knowledge to facilitate retrieval for application and transfer. Learners must be able to use metacognitive strategies, and must have follow-up support in the learning community to monitor and incorporate their goals.

A beginning point. The first design feature for the site will allow parents to respond to a teacher’s request to “Tell (a particular thing) about your child.” The parent’s response will return to the teacher on a simple format that can be displayed beside the student’s classwork on the same topic. The site will include links to help and encourage parents in their role and to represent the goals of the site.

RESEARCH SYNTHESIS OF HOW PEOPLE LEARN
The key principles of how people learn were synthesized by The National Academies and reported in a single volume by Bransford, et. al. (2000). But before the impact of their work will be felt in the classroom, they submit that their findings must be substantially elaborated at a useful level of detail and incorporated into curricula, instructional tools, and assessment tools according to the needs of teachers, administrators, policy makers, researchers, and the public (p 251). Teams will combine the expertise of researchers with the wisdom of practitioners, focusing more on the study of classroom practice than on laboratory environments. Our position is clear—instructional designers must provide essential tools to help teachers help people learn.