QUESTION FIVE
A key element in the connoisseurship and criticism approach of Elliot Eisner is expertise. A person who has it looks at the world differently, and is more qualified to conduct inquiry than a person who does not. Setting aside for a moment your natural reticence to extol your own qualifications, describe the elements of expertise that you would bring to your study of the teacher’s cultural realm in the question above, as well as your assessment of the parameters and limitations of that expertise. Be sure to include attitudinal, cognitive, and motor skill dimensions as applicable. (Note: your response to this question should not shape how you respond(ed) to question #4 above).
FROM MY PERSPECTIVE
What elements of expertise could I bring to the research scenario in the previous question? Well, let’s say that I’ve been working with this really great research team to figure out how to learn more about the teacher’s realm. But a teacher’s classroom is a tough realm to get into, forget about getting into it without altering the environment.
But wait, Elliot Eisner lends insight to our research plight (1991). One must drink deeply to savor his incredible wisdom, so more about that in a minute. Like Dr. Eisner, I’ve been a public school teacher for many years. Like him, I have a certain fetish about the arts. Actually it’s a good thing that everybody on our research team doesn’t share Dr. Eisner’s views as much as I do. Our diversity helps us to balance out each other’s biases.
I take Dr. Eisner’s interesting French term, connoisseurship, as synonymous with expertise. The two terms can be used interchangeably. Expertise implies the qualitative nuances and energy that come of metacognitive processes and transfer (Bransford, Brown, and Cocking, 2000), just as connoisseurship does. Criticism follows connoisseurship. The educational critic provides a public face for connoisseurship by communicating what is perceived. One cannot be a critic without some level of connoisseurship (Eisner, 1991, p 86). And as John Dewey pointed out in Art as Experience, criticism has at its end the re-education of perception (1934).
In all my years of teaching I’ve almost never observed how other teachers perform their work. A teacher working in the classroom with learners is not the same as a teacher working on a committee or on a grade level team, which I’ve seen plenty of. But Dr. Eisner says that to know what schools are like, their strengths and their weaknesses, we need to be able to see what occurs in them, and we need to be able to tell others what we have seen in ways that are vivid and insightful. We need to achieve a critic’s level of educational connoisseurship to recognize what counts, and we need to create a form of educational criticism to make what we see clear to those who have a stake in our schools (Eisner, 1991, p 22.)
Dr. Eisner goes on to say, “Raising [standardized] test scores might indeed be possible. But what, from an educational perspective, does it mean? Only by assessing the quality of teaching and the significance of the content being taught can we be in a position to make such judgments. This requires appraising education in ways akin to those in which critics appraise novels, films, poetry, and art. It requires judgment, and such judgments depend upon connoisseurship in the field in which the work is done (p 23).
Vladimir Nabokov observes,
“A lily is more real to a naturalist than it is to the ordinary person. But it is still more real to the botanist. And yet another stage of reality is reached with that botanist who is a specialist in lilies” (in Eisner, 1991, p 63).
Thus, the botanist who is a specialist looks at lilies differently and is more qualified to conduct inquiry about them than a person who has not conceptualized the vast repertoire of knowledge that is relevant to their domain. According to Miller (1956), only a subset of that knowledge is relevant to any particular problem. Experts and connoisseurs do not have to search through everything they know in order to find what is relevant; such an approach would overwhelm their working memory.
Experts have not only acquired knowledge, but are also good at retrieving the knowledge that is relevant to a particular task. In the language of cognitive scientists, experts’ knowledge is “conditionalized”—it includes a specification of the contexts in which it is useful (Simon, 1980; Glaser, 1992). Knowledge that is not conditionalized is often “inert” because it is not activated, even though it is relevant (Whitehead, 1929) (in Bransford et al, 2000). Thus, instructional technologists seek connoisseurship in the domains of learning and education.
Dynamics of learning. Computer environments can assist students with strategies that promote expertise (Lajoie & Derry, 1993). An issue that arises, though, is the conceptual understanding of the reciprocal influences among learner, tool, and learning environment. Assessment of the whole environment, not merely the effects of the tool as an isolated component, becomes critical.
The need to evaluate whole environments creates a second issue; finding the methodological means through which the changes in the environment can be documented and studied (Bransford et al, 2000). My response to the question above outlines a methodology for studying the whole cultural realm of teachers while they are in their workspace, thanks to the work of leaders in the field such as Jordan and Henderson (1995).
THE RESEARCH TEAM
I am excited and a little intimidated to be working with a team of professional researchers and Subject Matter Experts (SMEs). The expertise that I bring to this group derives from my love of research and from serendipitous events, but before I share those, my formal qualifications are: Master of Education state certified teacher for 29 years, English major and early childhood minor. That’s it—plus the coursework for my doctoral program.
The serendipity. I graduated from Logan High School at age 16 and married Don, the authentic cowboy of my dreams, in 1959. That was before the youth in our area had been admonished to wait until age 16 to even date. That summer I was called by my church to teach a Laurels class of young women, which I did with great trepidation for the next two years. I was teaching! But I was the one being taught. Each Tuesday evening I greeted my girls with my heart in my throat and my hands cold as ice. My young women and I grew and bonded. We learned. What they didn't realize, though, was that most of them were older than their "leader."
Twenty years later Don and I found ourselves with a total of six beautiful children, ages 18 down to 1. Don had encouraged me to take a writing class at Weber State College (now WSU), the first of many classes that led to a teaching career.
Locating “myself” in the literature. It’s been fun to discover the values of qualitative folks like Nel Noddings, who brings the quality of happiness into education, Harry Wolcott who “thinks in threes” and uses the branches of a large tree (instead of straight rows and columns) to represent the organization of qualitative research, and Dr. Eisner who is a defender of the student whose expertise lies in the metacognitive areas of music, dance, sports, or the visual arts. I’d never have found such treasures in the literature if someone hadn’t pointed the way.
Qualifications. I am a budding expert in a few small things, such as where to look or who to ask for guidance in the design of effective evaluation instruments and the selection of appropriate methodologies for research. I will always look for the expertise of the leaders in my field. For now I have the privilege of being mentored by my research team.
Limitations. We as a research team like to think of ourselves as a group of subject matter experts (SMEs) with access to best practices. One or more of us will always be a connoisseur and mentor in areas where others of us may be novices. If all are novices in regard to some aspect of the work, the abstract representations of knowledge we possess will transfer to help us chip away at solutions (Bransford et al, 2000).
Why I’m here. The mention of technology is very often pushed to the background of those whom it serves, the human family. In 1990 my youngest daughter and I were walking through a poor neighborhood in Recife, Brazil on our way to a hardware store when we saw a young girl watching us. I later wrote in my journal, “A girl, six or seven years old, stood in the doorway of a little shack dressed in tattered rags. Her eyes met mine for a moment as we passed by. I’m sure that I gasped with astonishment because she made such an impression on me. I saw something in her glance that I can only describe as an impression of intelligence. We went on about our business, but I felt that we had passed near someone of profound importance."
Because of this type of experience, similar to the experiences of many others that I’ve heard of or read since that time, I’d like to join my area of expertise with other researchers and instructional designers to learn about and assist the amazing teachers of the world in weaving the threads of family and culture throughout globalized and localized curriculum. Our tools are technologies.
At this time I’m grateful for the fabulous opportunity to be guided by the connoisseurs and skilled critics of my graduation committee and for the great patience I see that all of this requires. Thank you.
