Sunday, January 27, 2008

COMPS #2

THE QUESTION
Discuss parent involvement from a cultural perspective paying particular attention to ways to involve parents that are culturally and developmentally appropriate. Cite relevant extant literature. Develop, articulate, and discuss 8 “truths” or “guidelines” that teachers could use in their various teaching contexts to involve parents in meaningful and productive ways in their children’s education.

TEACHERS ARE KEY TO
PARENT INVOLVEMENT IN CLASSROOMS
teachers play the key role in providing the necessary entry paths for busy parents to participate in childrens’ classrooms. Districts and schools urgently need to provide effective training, tools, materials, sufficient staffing, and time for teachers to do it (Trumbull, Rothstein-Fisch, Greenfield, and Quiroz, 2001, p 29 and p 51).

Barriers to home-school partnerships. Traditional methods of home-school partnering are fraught with obstacles and concerns. Usually schools fail to involve all parents, particularly those from minority communities. School involvement may be quite one-sided, offering school-centered programs that accommodate volunteer parents, or sessions that teach parenting skills from the perspective of the school’s majority population (Trumbull, et. al., 2001). While these are steps forward, the needs of many families remain unmet—which impacts the children of those families. Training for teachers to facilitate family-centered parent involvement has been pushed down the priority list in favor of more immediate methods for raising standardized test scores—methods that, according to Hart and Risley, fade or wash out in time without sufficient connections with the child’s family and follow-up to support the transfer of new knowledge (1995).

Cultural dynamics. Values, goals, and views of fulfillment differ from family to family, and differ over time within families or cultural groups. Elise Trumbull and her colleagues provide a useful framework for teachers to think about cultural diversity without categorizing human beings or their cultures (2001). To think of all families on a continuum of individualism / collectivism representing the degree to which a culture emphasizes individual fulfillment and choice versus interdependent relations, social responsibility, and the wellbeing of the group (Trumbull, et. al, 2001). Many immigrant families are strongly collectivistic, for example, while many Euro-American families are strongly individualistic.

Communicating across cultures. Understanding the individualism / collectivism continuum can help teachers to recognize that useful knowledge resides in the community from many perspectives and in more than one language (Dauber and Epstein, 1993, in Trumbull, et al., 2001). Seeing parents as sources of cultural knowledge about the community can help teachers to initiate more effective two-way communication, a type of relationship referred to as “parallel practices” between home and school (Shockley, Michalove, and Allen, 1995, p 91-96). The interactions of educators, parents, students, and community members will not always be smooth or successful, but partnering with parents can establish a foundation of respect and trust on which to build (Epstein, 1995).

Creating a two-way path. Teachers can learn about the types of metaphoric and narrative questioning sequences that children of minority culture groups are familiar with and draw these children into two-way conversations using question techniques they are accustomed to and can readily respond to. Examples are given in the report entitled How People Learn from The National Academies (Bransford, Brown, and Cocking, 2000, p 106-108) of how teachers can initiate with a child the sharing of an experience, joint picture book reading, and interactive narratives. In general these techniques have obvious implications for literacy appreciation in preschool and early grades. Such techniques are needed to devise interventions to help minority-culture parents prepare their children for school. The answer, according to Heath (1981), is not to concentrate exclusively on changing children or changing schools, but to encourage adaptive flexibility in both directions (in Bransford, et al, 2000, p 111).

Six ways to involve parents. A framework of six major types of parent involvement has evolved from many studies and from many years of work by educators and families in elementary, middle, and high schools. The framework is reported by Joyce Epstein (1995) for the purpose of helping researchers locate their questions and results in ways that inform and improve practice. Briefly, parent involvement can include (1) parenting and parenting skills, (2) communicating about school and student, (3) volunteering, (4) learning at home (see Epstein’s TIPS program, revised 2001), (5) decision making, and (6) collaborating with the community (Connors & Epstein, 1995). Teachers are most often directly involved with initiating types 2, 3, and 4, and sometimes of type 1 of parent involvement in schools.

"TRUTHS" FOR TEACHERS
Parents need to be regarded by teachers as the child’s first and most influential teachers. School teachers, then, serve in a supportive role to parents to provide guidance and facilitation for learning. This supportive role places school teachers in a wonderful position, according to Shockley, et al, to demonstrate multicultural respect while monitoring clear expectations for the parents and families of their students (1995).

With planning, an effective teacher can scaffold not only for students learning, but also for parenting success, through well-planned home-school literacy-learning activities. The dynamic character of the teacher’s tasks presents a challenge to instructional designers to provide computer mechanisms to help teachers improve parent involvement and thus improve learning across cultures. Eight guidelines for teachers to promote parent involvement and for designers to develop future dynamic tools are suggested below:

1. Extend a welcoming hand to parents. Joyce Epstein stated, “The way schools care about children is reflected in the way schools care about the children’s families” (1995). If parents feel valued by their child’s teacher, they are likely to feel more confident in parenting. While teachers are not responsible for a parent’s sense of empowerment, they are positioned wonderfully to help facilitate parents’ understanding of the important role they play in their children’s lives” (Keyser, 2006, p 9).

2. Make program expectations clear. Once a program is successful in creating a welcoming environment, a plan to provide clear guidelines for expectations and goals to keep the environment learner- and knowledge-centered must be in place. A notice can be posted in the classroom reminding families about the classroom guidelines for adults and small children (Keyser, 2006, p 124).

3. Seek cultural knowledge. Educators can become “ethnographers,” in effect eliciting information about their cultures from the parents of the children they teach, as well as from paraprofessional aides and other community members (Trumbull, et al, 2001, p 51). Keyser claims that simply acknowledging all the information family members have about their child and their family can help to make the home-school partnership more equal (2006). Families know the child’s and the family’s history, and families do affect the child’s future through their hopes, plans, and goals.

4. Provide mechanisms for parents to become involved. Frameworks and scheduled hours can be provided for parents so that they may schedule around it for classroom activities. For involvement at home, student-authored traveling books or themed literacy bags can provide excellent mechanisms for parents to become involved in shared reading and writing experiences with their child (Burningham and Dever, 2005). Traveling books and literacy bags are a Type 4 activity (Epstein, 1995). A teacher could provide a mechanism to obtain a small tidbit of written knowledge from the parent to display alongside the student’s work on the same topic.

5. Meet the needs of single parents, or parents that may work at more than one job. Those who cannot spend time in the school will be able to represent themselves in their child’s schooling experience through asynchronous mechanisms provided by the teacher, such as a request to send a photograph, a cultural item, or a family-based story that their child can share at author’s chair or in the reading corner. Better computerized mechanisms are needed to improve home-school communications for parents who cannot come in, but non-computer options for those mechanisms must also remain available.

6. Meet the needs of English Language Learners (ELL families). School districts should provide the translations of home-school communications that teachers request. Parents should be given options to contribute to the learning environment in their native language or in two languages. A teacher can demonstrate respect for native languages by inviting ELL parents to share and teach a native phrase, poem, or song to the English-speaking peers of their child. Teachers can help students to take some responsibility for involving their parents in small ways with interactive homework and for returning the work.

7. Mentor reading techniques that parents can use at home. Techniques can be modeled briefly with parents on Back-to-School night or at a workshop for parents. Simple instructions can accompany traveling books or literacy bags as they circulate to student’s homes. Students can be encouraged to mentor for their parents the techniques they have learned at school. Home-school communications can remind parents how to encourage their child’s efforts.

8. Give and Invite feedback. Formative and summative assessments of ongoing parent involvement should be integrated into the home-school mechanisms that teachers employ. For example, interactive homework can include a small feedback section where parents can respond to or make suggestions about the experience (Epstein, 1995).

CONCLUSION
Teachers and parents need support to practice what research has found to work. Schools need to provide adequate and effective training and follow-up for teachers, as well as sufficient staffing to accomplish the teacher’s many instructional tasks.